Sir James Kempt,
Governor-General—1828. Lord Aylmer, Governor-General—1830. Lord Gosford,
Governor-General—1835. The Commission on Grievances fails to conciliate
disaffection- -Sir John Colborne assumes chief military command—1837.
Collision at Montreal, November 6th—Colonel Wetherall routs rebels at
St. Charles, November 25tli—Lord Durham, Governor-General and High
Commissioner—] 838. His magnanimous character—He exiles leaders and
pardons other rebels - His policy condemned as ultra vires—His chagrin
and resignation—His masterly Report. '
In Lower Canada, in the
meanwhile, the liberal concessions of the Home Government were met by
increased and unreasonable demands. The object sought was not, as in
Upper Canada, the establishment of- responsible government, but to
effect the supremacy of the French race and its absolute control over
the executive.
The conciliatory policy
of Sir James Kempt, who succeeded Lord Dalhousie in 1828, equally with
that of Lord Aylmer, who became Governor in 1830, failed to satisfy the
aggressive demands of the Assembly. During the summer of 1831, an
immigration of fifty thousand souls, chiefly Irish, arrived at Quebec,
and passed up the valley of the St. Lawrence, "like a disorganized
army," said a contemporary journal, "leaving the inhabitants to provide
for the sick and wounded and to bury the dead." The dreadful ravages of
the cholera, which spread from Grosse Isle over the whole country,
carried death and dismay to almost all the frontier towns and villages.
Three years later, a still more fatal visitation of the cholera
occurred.
Lord Gosford was
appointed to succeed Lord Aylmer in the ungrateful office of Governor,
and with him were asso-1835 Charles Grey and Sir George Gipps as a
commission of inquiry to investigate the alleged grievances of the
Assembly. These liberal measures failed to conciliate the French
majority. Papineau, the idol of the ignorant habitants, intoxicated with
power, boldly avowed his republican principles. The French were known to
be secretly drilling, and loyal volunteer associations were formed among
the British population for the defence of the Government.
1837 Wearied by the
rejection of its policy of conciliation, the Home Government now adopted
one of a more vigorous character. For five years the Assembly had voted
no civil list. The British officials and judges were reduced to extreme
distress. The Governor-General was empowered to take £142,000 out of the
treasury to pay these arrears. The demand for an elective Council was
refused. The indignation of the French population was intense. Turbulent
assemblies met with arms in their hands. Lord Gosford issued a
proclamation forbidding .these seditious gatherings. The accession,
after an interval of a century and a quarter, of a female sovereign
awoke no feelings of loyalty in the rebel faction, and they plotted as
vigorously against the throne and crown of Queen Victoria as they had
against the citizen King, William IV.
Never was a people less
fitted for the exercise of political power than the French habitants.
Nine-tenths of them were unable to read, and none of them had any spark
of that love of constitutional liberty in which the English nation had
so long been trained. Apparently the liberal party in Lower Canada, they
yet advocated reactionary measures, and strove to revive the old French
policy of resistance to popular education, immigration, or any
innovation of English customs, laws, language, or institutions.
To meet the coming
storm, Sir John Colborne, a prompt and energetic officer, was appointed
to the military command of the provinces. The few troops in Upper and
Lower Canada, only some three thousand in all, were chiefly concentrated
at Montreal, the focus of disaffection. But Papineau, the leader of the
rebellion, was an empty gas-conader, void of statesmanship or military
ability. Dr. Wolfred Nelson, the second in command, was of English
descent, born in Montreal, and speaking French 'like a native. As the
summer waned the symptoms of revolt increased. The French tri-colour and
eagle appeared, and turbulent mobs of "Patriots" or of "Sons of Liberty"
sang revolutionary songs. At length an armed collision with the
loyalists in the streets of Montreal (November 6th, 1837), in which
shots were fired, windows broken, and the office of the Vindicator, a
radical paper, wrecked,- although no one was killed, brought matters to
a crisis.
The insurgents
rendezvoused at St. Charles and St. Denis, on the Richelieu, where there
was considerable disaffection among the population. On the 23rd of
November, Colonel Gore, with three hundred men and only one cannon,
attacked Dr. Nelson, and a large body of rebels, at the latter place.
Papineau, on the first appearance of danger, deserted his dupes and fled
over the border into the United States. Nelson, strongly posted in a
large stone brewery, maintained a vigorous defence. Gore's command, worn
out with a long march through November rain and mire, out-numbered and
without artillery for battering the stone walls, was compelled, after
six hours' fighting, to retreat.
Two days later, Colonel
Wetherall, with four or five hundred troops, attacked a thousand rebels
under "General" Brown, at St. Charles. After a brief resistance the
rebels fled, leaving a number of slain. Nelson now fled from St. Denis,
but after ten days' skulking in the snowy woods was caught, and, with
many other rebel prisoners, lodged in Montreal jail.
Martial law was now
proclaimed. In the middle of December, Sir John Colborne, with two
thousand troops, left Montreal to attack a thousand insurgents
intrenched at St. Eustache, on the Ottawa. The main body fled, but four
hundred threw themselves into the church and adjacent buildings. The
shot and shells of the cannon soon fired the roof and battered the
walls. Many were killed or wounded, and many more made prisoners
Lord Gosford was now
recalled, though without any censure of his policy. The Home Government
suspended the constitution of the country, and appointed the Earl of
Durham Governor-General and High Commissioner for the settlement of
public affairs in the two Cana-das. He was a nobleman of great political
experience, and had been educated in a liberal school. His personal
character was attractive, and his private hospitality princely. He was
to the last degree unmercenary, refusing any recompense for his
distinguished services. He was refined and courteous in manner, but
tenacious of his convictions of duty, and firm in carrying them into
execution. On his arrival in the country, May 27th, he announced himself
as the friend-and arbitrator of the people, without distinction of
party, race or creed. And amply he fulfilled his pledge in the spirit of
the purest and most disinterested statesmanship. He appointed a
commission of inquiry into the state of the country, and redressed many
grievances in the public administration. An amnesty was granted to the
great mass of the rebel prisoners, which was appropriately proclaimed on
the day appointed for the coronation of the maiden Queen—June 14th.
Humanely unwilling to appeal to the arbitrament of a court-martial, the
Governor banished Wolfred Nelson and eight other leading insurgents to
Bermuda —a light penalty for their crime—and forbade Papineau and other
fugitive rebels to return to the country, under pain of death.
The Imperial
Parliament, however, annulled the ordinance as ultra vires, but
indemnified the Governor and Council for their well meant but
unconstitutional act. The proud and sensitive earl resigned his
commission, and returned to
England a
broken-hearted and dying man. His report on the state of Canada is a
monument of elaborate and impartial research, and prepared the way for
the union of the provinces, and the subsequent prosperity of the
country.
The departure of the
Earl of Durham was the signal for fresh outbreaks. The Habeas Corpus Act
was again suspended, and troops were distributed through the disaffected
regions to protect the loyal inhabitants. On Sunday, November 5th, an
attack was made on the Indian village of Caughnawaga for the purpose of
seizing the arms and stores deposited there. The Christian Indians,
rushing out of the church in which they were assembled, raised the
war-whoop, and captured sixty-four of the attacking party.
Robert Nelson, a
brother of the exiled revolutionary leader, crossed the frontier with a
large body of rebel refugees and American sympathizers, and proclaimed a
Canadian republic. On the 9th of November, two hundred militia at
Odelltown, posted in the Methodist church, kept at bay a thousand of the
insurgents, and drove them over the border, with the loss of several
killed and wounded. The revolt was promptly crushed^ but with extreme
severity.
The rash and infatuated
outbreak of the deluded habitants was the cause of much bloodshed and
misery, and was utterly unjustifiable by their circumstances. They
enjoyed a larger degree of liberty than did their race in any other
country in the world, and every possible concession of the Imperial
Government to their requests was met only by more unreasonable demands.
The duped and ignorant people were lured on to destruction by restless
and designing demagogues, who in the hour of danger abandoned them to
their fate, seeking selfish safety in flight. |