BRITISH REGIME
WRITERS ON THE CONSTITUTION, THE U. E. LOYALISTS, AND THE WAR OF 1812.
To the French-Canadian
sources of the native history, prior to and subsequent to the Conquest,
we have already referred. The chief of these, as we have said, is
Garneau's work, which may be profitably supplemented by Miles' history,
and by the Anglo-Canadian authors, MacMullen, Dr. Withrow, and Mr.
Andrew Archer, an able educational writer and historian of New
Brunswick. At the present moment we are looking forward with interest to
the appearing of an addition to the ranks of native historical writers,
in the person of Mr. Wm. Kingsford, C.E., of Ottawa, from whose pen we
are shortly to have a History of Canada to the date of the cession of
the country to Britain. Here we must find place to mention—in connection
with the successive constitutions granted to the people by the British
Crown, including the King's proclamation after the Conquest, the Quebec
Act of 1774, the Constitutional Act of 1791, the Act of Union, 1841, and
the British North America Act, which gave shape and form to
Confederation—Mr. Samuel J. Watson's "Constitutional History of Canada,"
of which the first volume only appeared. Dr. J. G. Bourinot's
"Parliamentary Procedure and Practice " also claims notice, in the
opening chapter of which the learned and industrious Clerk of the House
of Commons has given us a concise and lucid history of parliamentary
institutions in Canada. Dr. O'Sullivan's popular "Manual of Government
in Canada" may also be profitably consulted. The student of the Canadian
Constitutions will find, with regard to the latest of them, a number of
elucidatory textbooks well worthy of study, the chief of which is one by
Joseph Doutre, Q.C., of Montreal, illustrating the British North America
Act of 1867 by a series of annotations and recent decisions of the
Supreme Court of Canada and the Imperial Privy Council. Dr. Alpheus
Todd's important treatise on "Parliamentary Government in the British
Colonies" (London and Boston, 1880), is, with his earlier work,
doubtless too important to be unknown to the reader. The author's
learned commentaries, despite the buckram of his style, are held in high
repute wherever English institutions are studied or introduced.
The outbreak of the
American Revolutionary War, Montgomery's futile invasion of Canada in
1775, and the friction between the British and French races in Lower
Canada, which the Quebec Act of the previous year occasioned, gave birth
to three volumes on the peculiar land system prevailing in Lower Canada,
by Francis Maseres, at one time Attorney-General of the Province of
Quebec. These volumes, entitled "The Canadian Freeholder," discuss, in
the form of a dialogue between an Englishman and a Frenchman, the
burning land question of the day, in the interests of the Protestant
minority of the province, who were then, as they are still, at great
disadvantage in civil and ecclesiastical matters, in consequence of the
privileges granted at the Conquest to their French-Canadian and Roman
Catholic countrymen. The author, who subsequently became a Baron of the
Exchequer Court in England, also published a number of works advocating
the creation by the Crown of a House of Assembly and parliamentary
institutions in the Quebec Province. Referring to the Montgomery
invasion, reminds us of Mr. John Lesperance's novel, "The Bastonnais"
(Toronto, 1877), which gives a graphic account of it, and forms with Mr.
Win. Kirby's historial romance, "Le Chien D'Or "—a story of the old
courtly days of Louis Quatorze and Louis Quinze in Quebec—the two finest
pieces of fiction which English-Canada has so far produced.
Popular assemblies were
little to the mind of George III., and though the province was granted a
Constitution, the autocratic Executive and Legislative Council which
were given to it could scarcely be deemed a boon to the people. Nor
could the British and Protestant minority relish the recognition by the
State of the Roman Catholic Church, with legalization of the Civil Code
of France, and the perpetuation of the status of a French province. For
the period the province ran a separate career, namely, from 1791 to the
Union in 1841, Mr. Robert Christie's "History of Lower Canada,
Parliamentary and Political," in six volumes, 12mo (Quebec, 1849-55), is
the chief text-book and repertory of facts. Mr. Christie, as an active
member of the Legislature, had good opportunities for studying the
workings of the parliamentary institutions of the Province; and, though
his style is loose and straggling, he has made fair and intelligent use
of them.
The war for American
independence, now an accomplished fact, created an episode in the
history of Canada of which native literature has as yet made little, if
we except the two portly volumes of materials for a history compiled by
the late Rev. Dr. Ryerson, and published in Toronto in 1881.
Unfortunately, in these volumes, "The Loyalists of America and their
Times," though it was the design of the reverend gentleman that his work
should be, as he phrased it, "an historical monument to the character
and merits of the fathers and founders of his native country," the
author has occupied himself too much in re-telling the story of the
settlement of Massachusetts, and of the doings of the Puritan Fathers,
and has not devoted that space to the incidents of settlement in Upper
Canada which, for our own people, would have had an entrancing interest,
and been the most acceptable contribution to the native history.
Nevertheless, the work has many claims upon Canadian readers, and the
author's enthusiasm in his subject, and years of industry in compiling
his materials, though, as Ave have said, he has not made the best use of
them, deservedly entitle his work to notice and commendation. Hardly
more satisfactory in a literary point of view, though equally worthy of
honour as material for a history of the origin and progress of the
people of Ontario, is Dr. Wm. Canniff's "The Settlement of Upper Canada,
with special reference to the Bay of Quinte" (Toronto, 1869). The work
is unfortunately rare. The proceedings, in 1884, at Adolphuston,
Toronto, and Niagara, in connection with the celebration of the
Centennial of the settlement of Upper Canada by the U. E. Loyalists,
were published in Toronto, in 1885, and will be found to be of
considerable historic interest.
With the coming of
Governor Simcoe, Upper Canada was erected into a separate province, in
the opening up of which the sturdy band of incoming Loyalists rendered
yeoman service, and subsequently gave of its richest brain power in
laying the foundation of the young Western Commonwealth. What progress
had been made may be seen, less than twenty years afterwards, when the
province rose in its might to maintain its integrity against an
unprovoked and a foolhardy American invasion. In the patriotism which
the War of 1812 evoked, literature was a sharer, and has since done not
a little to commemorate in honour the doughty deeds and stirring
incidents of the brief but sanguinary conflict. The chief narrators,
among the eye-witnesses, of the events of the period, are two in number,
Lieut-Col. W. F. Coffin, and Mr. David Thompson, late of the Royal
Scots, a long-time resident of Niagara. Another historian of the
conflict, who deals with it, like Coffin and Thompson, in a distinct
work, apart from the general history, is Mr. Gilbert Auchinleck, editor
of the Anglo-American Magazine, in which periodical his patriotic
narrative appeared in 1855. Thompson's work was published in Niagara in
1832, and has the advantage in preserving many interesting incidents of
the unequal struggle, undimmed by time and the advancing age of
eye-witnesses. Col. Coffin's work, "The War of 1812 and its Moral," is a
deeply interesting and impartial narrative, in which is interwoven
records of the personal parts taken in the conflict by many U. E.
Loyalists and chivalrous scions of old French-Canadian families of noble
birth. An incomplete narrative of the War, containing an account of the
operations of the Right Division of the Canadian army, also appeared at
Brockville in 1842, from the pen of Major John Richardson, whose "Wacousta,"
an Indian tale, and "The Canadian Brothers," a story of the War of 1812,
are perhaps the best of the early productions in the department of
Canadian romance.
The general reader will
get a good idea of the War, and a graphic picture of the time, in a work
of fiction entitled "For King and Country," from the talented pen of
Miss Agnes Machar ("Fidelis"), of Kingston. Poetry and the drama have
also taken the war, or incidents in its progress, up for treatment. The
latest instance of this is Mrs. S. A. Curzon's "Laura Secord : the
Heroine of 1812," a dramatic version of a woman's heroic deed in warning
a British camp of danger from attack by the enemy. The closing year of
the War, with the patriotic part taken in it by an Indian ally of the
Crown, is also admirably portrayed in verse in Mr. Charles Mair's drama
of "Tecumseh," a work which is an honour to Canadian literature. Among
the many press reviews, which greeted this work on its appearing, will
be found a tribute to it and its talented author by the present writer
in the pages of The ' Varsity for 1885. The reference here to Tecumseh
recalls the name of another noble ally of Britain in the Revolutionary
War, whose biography (Stone's "Life of Chief Joseph Brant") though not
written by a Canadian, should be familiar to Canadians, and its subject
held by them in high honour. The same should be said for Stone's " Life
and Times of Sir Wm. Johnson," who for forty years (1738-1778) was Royal
Superintendent of Indian Affairs on this continent, and whose work is
replete with materials for Indian history during the exciting period
which preceded and followed the Conquest. Nor should the student of
Canadian history and literature be unfamiliar with Tupper's "Life and
Correspondence of Major-General Sir Isaac Brock" (London, 1845), the
hero of Queenston Heights, whose death on the battle-field repressed the
shouts of victory. |