AS already mentioned The Rev. Peter Ferguson entered upon
his work in Esquesing in April, 1832. Not long after this efforts began
to bring about the union of the United Synod of Upper Canada and the
Synod of the Presbyterian Church in Canada in connection with the Church
of Scotland. The Esquesing congregation, under the lead of Mr. Ferguson,
at a meeting held in December, 1833, voted to connect itself with the
Presbytery of York of the Church of Scotland, and appointed Mr.
Ferguson, Thomas Barbour and Thomas Chisholm to present the petition of
the congregation to Presbytery, and it was favorably entertained. The
elders of the Church at this time were John Creighton, Thomas Barbour,
Andrew Laidlaw and John Burns. In October, 1836, the following
additional elders were ordained:—John Storey, Donald McKinnon and David
Henderson.
In 1834 York had a population of 10,000, and by Act of
the Legislature was constituted a city with the name of Toronto, an
Indian word meaning “A place of meeting.” The Presbytery of York soon
afterwards became the Presbytery of Toronto.
At a congregational meeting in October, 1832, the
following resolution was passed:—"As The Rev. Peter Ferguson is now our
settled pastor, no other minister will be allowed to preach in this
house without his concurrence.” At the annual Meeting of the following
year another resolution was carried, which read:—“All proprietors of
this Church, from whatever sect of Presbyterians originally, so long as
they continue to support our minister, and the Society, shall have equal
right to sit in this house and vote at its meetings.” The disaffection
of a part of the congregation on account of the choice of Air. Ferguson
for pastor, and their preference for another brand of Presbyterianism,
now came to a head. The Scotch in the Old Country had considered it
their privilege to secede, and in Esquesing the disaffected withdrew
from the fold shepherded by Mr. Ferguson. Those who separated themselves
constituted an important and influential portion of the congregation,
and it was thereby weakened. They applied* to the Associated Synod of
North America for a supply of preachers, and decided to buy land and
erect a meeting house for themselves. The new Church edifice was erected
on Lot 6, Third Concesison East, and became known in the community as
the “Antiburgher Church.” In June, 1836, the Rev. Mr. Coutts was
ordained and installed pastor of the Associate, or Antiburgher,
congregation. As we look back now upon this first division in the
Esquesing congregation there does not seem to have been anything
important in the way of doctrine, or Church government, at stake, and
with more wisdom and grace on both sides the regrettable occurrence
would not have taken place.
The Esquesing congregation continued to grow, and
additions to Church membership to be made. People came long distances to
the services:—from the neighborhood of Acton and Limehouse, beyond
Glenwilliams, the vicinity of Norval, from Trafalgar and Nassagaweya;
and at first they walked, or rode on horseback, and later also in the
lumber-wagon. They came from a large territory, because the privileges
and blessings of the House of God were highly prized. Mr. Ferguson lived
in the beginning of his ministry in a house on the farm of Andrew
Laidlaw, near the Church, and then took up his residence on Lot 12,
Fifth Concession West, which he bought. He united in matrimony for
better, or for worse, but generally for better, many people, and his fee
was in money or farm produce. One man paid in beans, and another, who
was poor but honest, or because he liked to get something for nothing,
said:—“Mr. Ferguson, I will do as much for you some day.”
In 1837 two things came along to disturb the peace which
the congregation had been enjoying:—discussion of the “voluntary
question” and the rebellion. The ministers of the Established Church of
Scotland, under the terms of Union between England and Scotland had
received pecuniary aid from the State, and its ministers in Canada also
received it. In 1833 the ministers of the United Synod also began to
receive assistance. The Secession
Church in Scotland, however, had taken a stand against
the propriety of such aid, and when ministers from that Church organized
in 1834 “The Missionary 'Presbytery of the 'Canadas in connection with
the United Associate Synod of The Secession Church in Scotland,” they
maintained their principle that ministers of the Church and its work
should be supported by the voluntary contributions of the people. There
were a number of the Esquesing congregation who held strongly to this
principle, and their view was intensified by the unjust, and unseemly
claim of the Church of England to the exclusive right to the Clergy
Reserves—the one-seventh part of all the unceded lands of Upper Canada
and Lower Canada—which had been granted by an Act of the British
Parliament in 1791 for “the support and maintenance of a Protestant
clergy.” This claim had been asserted in such an offensive and arbitrary
way that it became one cause of the rebellion.
There were others: The actions of a body of men spoken of
as “The Family Compact,” who possessed almost all the offices of profit
and trust, disposed of a large number of petty posts, got into their
hands large tracts of land, holding back the settlement of the country,
and controlled the legislation to a large degree. Sir Francis Bond Head,
the Lieutenant-Governor, claimed that he was responsible only for his
acts to the Colonial Office of the Imperial Government, and was bound to
consult the Executive Council only when he had need of their advice. The
reformers of the day agitated for an elective Legislative Council, an
Executive Council responsible to public opinion, and the surrender of
the whole Provincial revenue into the hands of the Legislature. The
discontent of the people found a voice in William Lyon MacKenzie and
some others. After the collapse of the rebellion, chiefly organized by
him, by the defeat of his forces at Montgomery’s tavern on Yonge Street,
he fled westward to the Township of Nelson, and found his way over into
New York State. It was commonly believed, however, that he was in hiding
for a time in the Scotch Block where he had friends, and several houses
were searched for him. Feeling ran high among the inhabitants. While
most people sympathized with the cause of reform, they believed that the
cure of the evils of the time should be sought in responsible
government, and not in armed rebellion. These matters of Church and
State were much discussed in the Block and with very considerable
passion.
Those opposed to receiving pecuniary aid from the State
by ministers tried to have Mr. Ferguson refuse it, but he declined to
comply with their request. He needed the money, and saw no wrong in a
minister of the Church of Scotland accepting what the law gave him. The.
larger portion of the congregation, who were not opposed to their pastor
receiving State money, having ascertained the amount, voted that enough
should be added to it to make his stipend £100. Those who disapproved of
Mr. Ferguson receiving the Government grant withdrew, and attended the
Antiburgher Church, whose pastor was the young and popular Air. Coutts.
When he ceased to be pastor they along with some others left, and having
bought a piece of land on Lot 8, Concession 4 West, from John Stewart
Sr., erected a meeting house in 1844. The new organization became a
member of The Missionary Presbytery of the Canadas in connection with
the United Associate Synod of the Secession Church in Scotland, and was
known in the Block as the Seceder Church. In 1847, when the Missionary
Synod of Canada took the name of the “Synod of the United Presbyterian
Church in Canada" the Seceder Church in the Block was called the United
Presbyterian Church. The first pastor was The Rev. George Fisher. Among
those who became connected with the new congregation were several who
had been pronounced sympathizers with William Lyon MacKenzie. John
Stewart Jr., who had taken part in the uprising, and escaped to New York
State, where he remained for several years, became an elder of the
Church, and was one of the most respected men of the community. Another
very well known man may be mentioned here, viz:—Hugh Black, the
surveyor. He had come to Canada by way of the West Indies from Scotland.
He was a man of ability, had received a good education, and was a
practical surveyor in Scotland. He was living with his family in Norval
at the time of the rebellion. When Air. MacKenzie fled after its failure
a party of men came to Mr. Black’s house in his absence, and on the plea
of searching for MacKenzie and to prove their loyalty, damaged his
furniture and threw the clock out of doors.
It was well known that he favoured the reforms advocated
by MacKenzie and was a contributor to his newspaper. After Mr. Black
came to live on his farm in the Scotch Block he occasionally attended
the United Presbyterian Church, and when he died, in 1854, at the age of
sixty-two, his body was buried in its cemetery, but it was afterwards
exhumed and buried at Limehouse. Probably no man in the Block was more
spoken about in his day than Hugh Black, and generally in connection
with his work and experience as a surveyor, and for his numerous droll
stories and remarks, some of which are quoted, to this day.
The disturbances in the Scotch Block incident to the
Rebellion were of brief duration. Several years later, when Mr.
MacKenzie had returned to Canada after the Amnesty Act of 1849 had been
passed, he was invited by a committee of which Robert Robertson was
Chairman, to speak at a picnic in a grove on Lot 5, Concession 1, near
Ligny schoolhouse, which he did to a great crowd of people.
Two other congregations had now been formed out of the
First Presbyterian Congregation of Esquesing, and the three houses of
worship were near one another. It must have discouraged Mr. Ferguson to
lose so many people from his fold, but in the records of Session, of
which he was clerk throughout his entire ministry, he made no mention of
the matter whatever. He still “carried on.” If he lost members and
adherents he won new accessions to the Church and congregation.
He and his elders were faithful in exercising their power
of discipline, but it must have vexed his righteous soul that so much of
it had to be done. One man charged with inebriety admitted that he had
on one occasion taken more ardent spirits than was really necessary;
another accused of a similar offence proved his innocence, but asked to
be relieved of the office he held, inasmuch as some might still think
the charge was true. The fact is that strong waters were plenty and
cheap, and as a beverage very common. Few people were thought much the
less of for getting intoxicated now and then, but it did not seem quite
the right thing for a Church officer. The Session also disciplined
members for profanity, defamation of character, absence from Church
without good reason, and for gross transgressions of morality. The
sinning were suspended from Church membership until they brought forth
fruits meet for repentance, or they were solemnly rebuked and
admonished, while all were encouraged to try and do better.
The Esquesing congregation had to undergo the experience
of another division. Tn May, 1843, occurred what is known as the
Disruption in the Church of Scotland. Secessions, or disruptions, had
taken place in Scotland before, but this one was on a larger scale than
usual. It too was for “conscience” sake. “Nearly five hundred ministers,
including such men as Doctors Chalmers, Welsh, Candlish, Cunningham,
Guthrie, Gordon McFarlan and Buchanan, rather than submit to State
control, withdrew from the Established Church, surrendered their
Churches, manses and stipends, and with a large body of sympathizing
elders organized themselves, in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, the
sole King and Head of the Church, as the “Assembly of the Free
Protesting Church of Scotland.” The Synod of the Presbyterian Church of
Canada was deeply impressed by the struggle for spiritual independence
in the Church of Scotland, and at its meetings in 1842 and 1843
expressed its convictions regarding the right of congregations to choose
their own pastors, and its sympathy with the ministers, elders and
members, “who, leaving the Established Church at the bidding of
conscience, have thereby sacrificed temporal interests, and personal
feelings that must command the respect and admiration of the Christian
Church.”
The relation of the Church in Canada to the Church of
Scotland had to be determined. Delegates from the Established Church and
the Free Church in Scotland came to Canada, and defended the positions
taken by them, and there were intense interest and feeling among
Presbyterians here. The matter was discussed in Presbyteries and
Congregations.
When the Synod met in Kingston in July, 1844, there was
great divergence of opinion, but in the end Dr. Bayne of Galt, on behalf
of himself and those siding with him, laid on the table a document
containing their reasons for dissenting from the decision of the Synod
on the previous day, and “protesting that they could no longer hold
office in the Presbyterian Church of Canada in connection with the
Church of Scotland." The Rev. Mr. Stark, the moderator, and the Rev. Mr.
Rintoul, the Clerk of the Synod, both resigned their offices. On the
10th of July, 1844, the seceding ministers and elders met and organized
themselves into a Synod, which assumed the name of “The Synod of the
Presbyterian Church of Canada,” but which was usually called the “Free
Church.”
The Esquesing congregation divided as the Synod had done,
the minority remaining with Mr. Ferguson in connection with the Church
of Scotland, and the majority, although attached to Mr. Ferguson
personally, connected themselves with the Free Church. At a meeting of
the Session on October 20th, .1844, Andrew Laidlaw said that he could
not remain any longer in connection with the Church of Scotland as
elder, or member, and tendered his resignation of the eldership. The
Session urged him to take longer time for consideration, but he insisted
that his resignation should be accepted. The elders who remained with
Mr. Ferguson were Thomas, Barbour, John Storey and David Henderson. Both
congregations claimed the meeting house, but it was amicably arranged
that both should have the use of it, but at different hours on the
Sabbath.
Mr. Ferguson continued as pastor of the Church of
Scotland congregation for a number of years. The last meeting of the
Session at which he presided as moderator was held on July 15, 1855.
On August 1, 1847, he and The Rev. Alexander McKid of
Hamilton officiated at the opening services of St. Andrew’s Church,
Milton, and he continued as pastor there for ten years. His last meeting
of Session of the Milton Church was on May 10, 1857.
Soon afterwards Mr. Ferguson sold his farm to David
Lindsay, and moved with his family to Kingston. There, two or three of
his sons attended Queens College School, which prepared boys for
entering the College. The principal of the School was Robert Campbell,
who at present, and for several years, has been known as The Rev. Robert
Campbell D.D., Clerk of the General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church
in Canada. Air. Ferguson returned
with his family to his farm, which was taken hack from
Mr. Lindsay, and died there in January, 1863, aged 63 years, and his
body was buried in the Boston Church cemetery, where a red granite
monument marks the spot. He was survived by his wife Isabella ’ Gale
Ferguson, a sister of The Rev. Alexander Gale, at one time pastor in
Hamilton and a leader in the Presbyterian Church, and also a sister of
Mrs. (Rev. Dr.) Ure of Goderich, and by three sons, John, Peter and
Alexander, and a daughter, Margaret. Peter Ferguson is still a familiar
name in the Scotch Block. |