Search just our sites by using our customised site search engine



Click here to get a Printer Friendly PageSmiley

Click here to learn more about MyHeritage and get free genealogy resources

The Real Reason Canada Never Became Part of the United States
The US took roughly half of Mexico and had over a million men under arms in 1865. So why did Canada, next door, never join?


Most people assume the answer is simple. Canada belonged to Britain, and no American president wanted a war with the British Empire. But American armies invaded Canada twice anyway, in 1775 and in 1812. A congressman brought in a bill laying out how the British provinces would become American states, and a senator argued that Britain owed more than two billion dollars. More than 300 Montreal men signed an annexation manifesto, and 104 residents of Victoria petitioned President Grant. The border came much closer to vanishing than most of us learned, and the usual explanation tells only part of why it held.

This documentary follows the story from the Quebec Act of 1774 and Richard Montgomery's attack on the walls of Quebec on December 31, 1775, to Bishop Briand, Benjamin Franklin's failed mission to Montreal, and the Loyalists who founded New Brunswick. It covers the Caroline affair, the Battle of the Windmill, the Oregon Treaty of 1846, the burning of the Montreal parliament, the Annexation Manifesto of 1849, Lord Elgin's Reciprocity Treaty of 1854, the St. Albans raid, the Fenian raids of 1866, and the British North America Act, given royal assent the day before William Seward signed for Alaska. It follows John A. Macdonald, the Victoria petition to Ulysses Grant, Charles Sumner's Alabama claims, the Treaty of Washington of May 8, 1871, and the Geneva award of 15.5 million dollars, and ends with the Canadian Pacific Railway, Champ Clark's North Pole speech, and the reciprocity election of 1911.

The story includes its human cost. Many Black Loyalists never received the land they were promised. Of some 15,000 Chinese railway workers, at least 600 lost their lives on the job, and Ottawa imposed a head tax on Chinese immigrants in 1885. On the prairies, Ottawa withheld rations from hungry First Nations to force them onto the reserves it chose. In 1885 Louis Riel was hanged, and eight Cree and Assiniboine men convicted of murder for killings during the rising were hanged at Battleford.

You can view this video on YouTube


Return to our History Page

Quantcast

Quantcast