In the reign of Charles
I. a duty of five per cent, had been imposed on the produce of all
foreign vessels engaged in the Newfoundland trade. Twenty-five years
later the French under Du Mont, then proceeding to Quebec with a
contingent of soldiers and colonists, established a settlement at
Placentia, on the southern coast, fortified .t, and made it the seat of
a resident Governor. They continued, however, to pay the duty in
recognition of English sovereignty. Charles II abolished the duty to
oblige his French patron, an J with the abolition began the history of
French aggression. Very soon after their establishment the French
settlers repudiated England's sovereignty over the south parts of
Newfoundland, and from time to tune strengthened their colony by
bringing over bands of French immigrants. It was clear to many that the
extension of French power in Canada and Newfoundland was a serious
menace to the English fisheries and settlements: leading statesmen,
however, refused to recognize the danger, and believed that if any
really existed, the system of convoys would obviate it. The
convoy-captains, enlarging the sphere of their regular activities, saved
the colony, and during their intermittent visits took upon themselves
the functions of governors, and effectually prevented the diffusion of
anarchy. The Governors of the French colony made their presence felt
more than the English settlers could tolerate ; they interfered with
them unduly, engaged in privateering expeditions and land forays against
them, destroyed their property, and burned down their houses. Indeed,
more than one French Governor conceived the notion, with the sanction of
the King of France, of putting an end entirely to English colonization
in the island. " The encroachments of the French," said William III., in
his Declaration of War, " on His Majesty's subjects trading and fishing
there, had been more like the invasions of an enemy than becoming
friends, who enjoyed the advantages of that trade only by permission."
With the outbreak of war came in sharp succession the attacks of
Chevalier Vesmond, and of Burriu, beneath the latter of winch all the
island but Bona vista and Carbonier succumbed.
The Treaty of Ryswick
in 1697 was signed before the French had been dislodged. LTnder its
terms the invaders surrendered their conquests and retired to the
terrtory in the south-west, of which they were in occupation when the
war began. The anomaly of their claims, passed over in silence by the
Treaty, was certain to be the source of mischief. In the language of Mr
Pedley, "Over a territory of some 200 miles m extent, belonging to the
British sovereignty, they had built up ;,npercep-tiblv an almost
undisputed dominion." Five years after the Peace of Ryswick war broke
out again An English squadron under Admiral Sir John Leake destroyed a
number of French fishing-vessels between St. Pierre and Trepassey
(1702), and in the following year Admiral Graydon failed to reduce
Placentia, owing to sickness, bad weather, as well as want of
resolution. In January 1705 the French in retaliation surprised and
captured St. John's. From this point they overran the English
settlements, Carbonier once again weathering the storm, and abandoned
themselves to depredation and devastation, as they had done in the
conflict a few years before.
The Treaty of Utrecht
in 1713 found the French still in possession. The provisions of this
Treaty require careful consideration. Full sovereignty over the whole of
Newfoundland and the neighbouring islands was declared to belong to
England. Placentia was to be handed over. Article XIII. of the Treaty
contains the following provisions :
"Nor shall the most
Christian King, his heir and successors or any of their subjects, at
anytime hereafter lay claim to any right to the said island. . .
Moreover, it shall not be lawful for the subjects of France to fortify
any place in the said island of Newfoundland, or to orect an}' buildings
there, besides stages made of boards, and huts necessary and useful for
drying of fish, or to resort to the said island beyond the time
necessary for fishing and drying of fish. But it shall be allowed to the
subjects of France to catch fish and to dry them on land in that part
only which stretches . . . from Cape Bonavista to the northern part of
the said island from thence by the western side as far as Cape Riche."
The fishing concession
to France herein contained was wholly inexcusable. The latter country
was in no position to refuse terms, and an absolute reservation of all
fishing rights should have been insisted on in the interests of the
colony. A culpable Ministry, short-sightedly regarding Newfoundland as
little more than a fishing-station, chose rather to make a graceful
concession, and we inherited the consequences in our Newfoundland
Fisheries controversy with France, which lasted for nearly two
centuries. However, the half century following the Treaty of Utrecht—an
important turning-point in the history of the colony--marks a period of
progress; and after another Anglo-French conflict, from which the
English emerged victorious, we find in the ensuing half century the
establishment of a definite policy' of colonial permanence.
The abuses connected
with the admirals' jurisdiction had been partially corrected by the
authority, on appeal from them, of the King's commanders stationed off
the island. Still, the evils were very real, and extorted recognition
even from the gang of west country monopolists who strangled for so long
the growth of the island. We find a recommendation offered by them to
the Board of Trade with astounding assurance, that the ,3000 odd men,
women, and children, who by this time composed the population of
Newfoundland, "should be encouraged to settle in Nova Scotia— as they
might be of service there, where inhabitants were wanted."
The colonists
themselves had other and better remedies. A spontaneously elected
Assembly passed ordinances which attest the sincerity of the general
desire for reform. In 1728 the informing zeal of Lord Yere Beaucleik
elicited a decisive step from the Board of Trade, and Captain Henry
Osborne was appointed the first Governor of Newfoundland (1729), with
authority to appoint justices of the peace. Even at such a moment the
cloven hoof of prejudice peeped through, and Osborne and his justices
were explicitly warned to interfere in no way with the privileges, of
the admirals, as defined by 10 and 11 William III. Governor Osborne
addressed himself to his duties with great energy. He appointed justices
and constables, carved the island into districts, and erected prisons
and stocks. His influence was weakened by his departure when the season
ended, for till ihe nineteenth century the governors, like the fish,
were migratory. A tedious quarrel followed between the justices and the
admirals as to the limits of their respective jurisdictions; the
admirals, whose wits seem to have been sharpened by judicial practice,
insisting that their own authority was derived from statute, whereas
that of the justices merely rested upon an Order in Council.
In 1749 the great
sailor Rodney, then a commander in the Navy, was appointed Governor, fie
distinguished himself by a humane consideration for the interests of the
fishing servants. His answer to a petition from the merchants for
permission to lower the contract rate of wages, in view of the badness
of the season, has often been quoted, and is pleasant to read:
"Mr Drake and myself
would be glad to ease the merchants in all that lay in our power, but we
are by no means capable of acting as desired, to serve any people
whatever. I have only one question to ask, namely: ' Had the season been
good in proportion as it has proved bad, would the merchants or
boat-keepers have raised the men's wages?'"
In 1750 came another
advance. Commissioneis of Oyer and Terminer were appointed for the
island; that is to say, persons authorized to " hear and determine " on
capital felonies committed in Newfoundland. This change ended the costly
farce by which such persons were sent to England for trial. Seven years
of development followed, to be broken by the long struggle between
England and France, which the splendid genius of Pitt inspired and
directed. He not only " conquered America in Europe " by the prodigal
carelessness with which he poured subsidies into the treasury of
Prussia, but he conceived and delivered in America itself a death-blow
to French ambition. In 1758 Amherst and Wolfe, with a fleet of 150
vessels, were sent to attack Cape Breton, and after assaulting
Louisbourg, the capital, received the submission of the island. In 1759
came General Wolfe's night assault on Quebec, and the unforgettable
battle in which he lost his life. The. only French success was gained at
the expense of Newfoundland, for St. John's surrendered to an
adventurous French expedition under Count d'Haussonville in June 1762.
Admiral Lord Graves, the Governor, who was on his voyage from England,
received the news in time to prevent him from landing. He vigorously
concerted a plan of attack with Admiral Lord Colville, who was in
command at Halifax, and after a lively investment the French garrison,
numbering 700 or 800 strong surrendered on terms (September 20th, 1762),
but the French Navy managed to escape, thanks to a fog.
The Treaty of Paris in
1763 brought the war to an end. Its course had afforded one more
opportunity of simplifying the condition of the fishing industry. The
Enghsh Ministry, under the nerveless guidance of Lord Bute, omitted to
seize it, and the Newfoundland clauses of the Treaty of Utrecht (which
had granted to the French fishery and drying rights on the coasts
between Cape Bonavista and Point Rich) were confirmed, notwithstanding
the fact that the English settlers had extended their occupation as far
north as Twillingate, and French fishermen had not for three decades
previously been further south than Fleur-de-Lys and White Bay. One
clear, protesting voice was heard. "I contended several times in vain,"
said Pitt, " for the whole exclusive fishery, but I was overruled—I
repeat, I was overruled, uot by the foreign enemy, but by another
enemy."
The House of Commons,
under George III., was a corrupt and discredited body; and the Treaty of
Paris was affirmed by 319 votes to 65. It had fallen to the lot of
Governor Pailiser— a fine reactionary in the view he took of his charge
— to frame local orders for carrying out the provisions of the Treaty of
Paris. His orders were clear and unambiguous. The French right of
fishing within the permitted area was declared to be concurrent. The
English jurisdiction was affirmed except in disputes between French
subjects.
Between the capture of
French America and the revolt of the older English colonies a few years
of peace intervened. Cook, the great discoverer, who had served under
Lord Graves in Newfoundland in 1762, spent the four years from 1763 to
1767 in an invaluable survey of the island, wherein he showed for the
first time its correct shape, and glancing inland foretold for it a
great mining future. The annexation of Labradoi, affected by the
proclamation of October 7th, 1763, added to the area and importance of
the .colony.
It would be
unreasonable to look for religious enlightenment in the early history of
Newfoundland. "Coelum non aniraurn mutant qui trans mare currunt": there
was little tolerance in the England of the eighteenth century, and even
the New England settlers had shamed their faith by outrages on the
Quakers. In Newfoundland- religious feeling ran high, as it has so often
done when Roman Catholics and Protestants live side by side. The Roman
Catholic element in Newfoundland, though a minority, was considerable in
numbers: for the sorrows of Ireland had brought many of her children
from one sorely tried island to another. The Protestant majority,
forgetting the tradition of Lord Baltimore, abused their supremacy.
Heavy fines were inflicted on priests for holding services, and the
scenes of their ministrations were burned to the ground. Mr Fedley
quotes a letter, written by Governor Donell, to a bench of magistrates
in 1762:
"Whereas I am informed
that a Roman Catholic priest is at this time in Harbour Grace, and that
he publicly read Mass, which is contrary to law, and against the peace
of our Sovereign Lord the King; you are hereby required and directed, on
the receipt of this, to cause the said priest to be taken into custody,
and sent round to this place In tins you are not to fail."
Mr Pedley quotes a
letter from Governor Bonfuy to certain justices, which grimly
illustrates the prevalence of crime in the eighteenth century:
"Whereas I think, for
the good of this island in general, that gallows should be erected in
the several districts, in order to deter from their robberies a parcel
of villains, who think that they can do what they please with impunity.
. . . You are, therefore, hereby required and directed to cause: gallows
to be erected in the most public places in your several districts, and
cause all such persons as are guilty of robbery, felony, or the like
crimes, to be sent round to this place in order to take their trial at
the annual assizes held here, as I am determined to proceed against all
such with the utmost severity of the law. Given under my hand at St.
John's, the 12th of October, 1754 "Newfoundland was naturally affected
by the rebellion of the American colonies. Of these Montcalm. in 1758,
had written with rare insight." The several advices I daily receive
assure me England will one day lose her colonies. As to the English
colonies, one essential point should be known it is, that they are never
taxed. The Mother Country should have taxed them from the foundation; I
have certain advice that all the colonies would take fire at being taxed
now." 1 The expulsion of the French from America had already lessened
the dependence of the colonies upon the home country, when the House of
Commons directed its corrupt and blighting attention to the English
colonial system. The Stamp Act was passed in 1764, and repealed in 1766.
In 1708 came Charles Townshend's mischievous duty on tea; and the
American Congress met at Lexington in 1774. At this time the resident
population of Newfoundland amounted to over 12,000 2 and it was soon
realized that the colony would be gravely affected by the outbreak of
war. Congress at once prohibited all trade with the English colonies.
The seriousness of this blow was extreme, for Newfoundland was largely
dependent upon the American trade for the necessaries of life. Want and
tempest worked together for ill, and the year 1775 is one of the
blackest in the history of the colony. The treaty with France in 1778
brought to the American colonists a success which their resources and,
it must be added, their resolution could hardly have won alone, and once
more exposed Newfoundland to European attacks. It was protected by the
energy and resource of Governor Montague.
In 1775 came the very
important Act known as Palliser's Act. This statute was based on the old
selfish and restrictive view that Newfoundland should be a training
ground for the Navy, and a place of trade not a permanent settlement.
Bounties were given to the fishing industry, and stringent measures were
provided to ensure that masters trading to the island should return with
undiminished crews. The privilege of drying fish was to be enjoyed only
by such of the King's subjects as sailed to Newfoundland from Great
Britain, or from one of the British dominions in Europe.
An interesting light
upon the economic condition of the colony is thrown by the following
figures:
Estimate of the sums
necessary to pay the salaries of the Governor and Civil Officers in the
Island of Newfoundland from April 1st, 1787, to April 1st, 1788:
It will be of interest
to give here a few figures as to the growth of the English population in
order to show that colonial developments were proceeding in the right
direction. " Residents grew apace, as the increase of women and children
from 612 in 1710 to 1,356 in t738, and to 2,508 in 1754 attested. Heads
of families accounted for a third more, so that in round numbers
permanent residents were 800 in 1710, 1,800 in 1738. and 3,400 in 1754.
The ship's crews of English ships, for whose sake the older theorists
taught that the fisheries primarily existed , numbered 3,600 in 1738 and
4,500 in 1754, so that they outnumbered residents, in the strictest
sense of the word residents. But if residents included all those who
wintered on the island, they outnumbered ship's crews during this
half-century. On the other hand, if passengers were added to ships'
crews, the visitors outnumbered the settlers, except when there were war
scares. . Between 1764 and 1774 residents for the first time
continuously outnumbered visitors. During these years the winter
residents, including male hangers-on as well as settlers, averaged
12,340; and visitors, including 'passengers' as well as ships' crews,
averaged 11,876; or excluding male hangers-on from the one side and
passengers from the other side, residents averaged 5,660 and visitors
5,435. Figures no longer yielded an uncertain sound. The Rubicon was
only just crossed, but was indisputably and irrevocably crossed.
Thenceforth the living-rooms were larger than the corridors, and
political arithmetic pointed at the permanent occupants as the men of
destiny. In 1764 the new tilt of the balance struck the law officers of
the Crown, who wrote that it was ' disgraceful to suffer' the Act of
1699 ' to remain in the Statute Book' as circumstances had so much
changed. This disproportion increased; and the 12,000 inhabitants of
1764-74 swelled to 17,000 in 1792, 20,000 in 1804, and 52,000 in 1822,
without any corresponding increase on the part of those who appeared
every spring and faded away every autumn, like leaves or flowers." |