Organization of Alberta Field Force Under
Strange—Measures for the Security of Settlers in Alberta—Missionaries as
Peacemakers—Strange's Northern March—Skirmishes Near Fort Pitt—A
Dangerous Situation—Battle of French man's Butte; an Unconscious
Victory—Middleton's Criticism and Dispatches—Steele's Pursuit of Big
Bear—Skirmish at Loon Lake—Shortage of Ammunition—Pursuit Continued
Among Unexplored Morasses—The Silent March—Conduct of French
Volunteers—Moral Importance of Closing Phase of Campaign—Death of
Colonel Williams—Middleton's Farewell to North West Field Force—Cost of
the Rebellion. It is now
necessary for us to turn back in our story to recount the doings of the
Alberta Field Force, under General Strange, a veteran of the Indian
mutiny.
On April 16th, the day of Middleton's
arrival at Clarke's Crossing, the 65th Battalion of Mounted Royal
Rifles, under Lieutenant-Colonels Ouimet and Hughes, arrived at Calgary
from Montreal. Strange's column also included the Winnipeg Light
Infantry, under Lieutenant-Colonel W. O. Smith, the 9th Battalion, under
Lieutenant-Colonel Aymot, a detachment of the Mounted Police with a
nine-pounder from Fort McLeod, under the command of Inspector Perry
(subsequently Commissioner), another detachment of Police Scouts under
Major Steele, and still another company of Scouts commanded by Major
Hatton. Altogether, Strange's forces amounted to about nine hundred.
Preparations for the defence of the
South Country were seriously hampered by the fact that the settlers
(owing to the protection hitherto enjoyed at the hands of the Mounted
Police) were almost entirely without arms. Moreover, the cowboys, who
themselves were but partially armed, could not be withdrawn from the
cattle districts among the Indian reserves, without placing at the mercy
of the Indian raiders valuable supplies of horses and cattle. Home
guards and local patrols were, however, organized.
General Strange's orders, from General
Middleton, as we have seen, were to overawe and restrain the Indians of
Alberta and Southern Athabasca, to protect the various settlements along
the railway and elsewhere, to march north to Edmonton and move thence
down along the Saskatchewan and make a juncture with Middleton himself.
Strange left Amyot's battalions as a garrison at Calgary, and provided
for the protection of McLeod and the railway lying to the east of
Calgary, stationed a company at Gleichen to guard the railway and
northern trails, and to keep watch over the Blackfeet; and then marched
his remaining troops in three columns to Edmonton.1 The advance force,
under Strange's personal command, moved north on April 20th. In addition
to Steele's sixty scouts and policemen, Strange had only one hundred and
fifty infantry to guard his long line of one hundred and seventy-five
wagons, which were sometimes unavoidably extended from a distance of one
and a half miles to two miles. The teamsters were unarmed, there being
no weapons available for them. That the convoy reached its destination
in safety was due, says General Strange, largely to the careful scouting
done by Major Steele's force. This column entered Edmonton on May 1st.
Inspector Perry was in command of the
second column from Calgary, which marched out on April 23d. He found the
Red Deer River impassable. The column under General Strange had forded
it twenty-four hours before with ease, but owing to the very heavy rains
it had risen rapidly and was now fully two hundred and fifty yards wide.
A raft was constructed, but owing to an accident it was carried some
three miles down the river before a landing was effected. Here there was
a cut bank thirty feet high, up which Perry's gun, carriage and
ammunition had to be hauled. A ferryboat was then constructed which
proved of great assistance to the column following. On arriving at
Edmonton, Perry turned his contingent over to General Strange.
In advance of Strange's contingent went
the heroic missionary, Father Lacombe, who, unaccompanied and despite
the difficulties of travel at that season of the year, visited all the
Indian reserves as a peacemaker, and succeeded in persuading the Alberta
Indians to maintain strict neutrality and remain quietly upon their
reservations. In these measures he was vigorously supported by the
famous Blackfoot chief. Crowfoot, and excellent service was also
rendered by the Rev. John McDougall, who had great influence, especially
among the Stoneys. Moreover, Lieutenant-
1 Before the arrival of Strange's
troops, Superintendent Cotton of Fort MacLeod offered to make a prompt
movement on Edmonton and Fort Pitt. In reply to this offer. Major
General Strange wrote Superintendent Cotton as follows:
"Your valuable services, knowledge of
the district, and influence with the Indians, render it important that
you remain where you are. I must therefore order you to do so. I can
understand your desire to go to what you consider the front, but the
front may at any time become the rear, and visa versa."
Governor Dewdney was communicating with
the Indians through Father Scollen.
It is impossible here to relate in
detail the valuable work performed by various police officers in the
south country, and throughout what is now Alberta, but mention must be
made of Superintendent Mclllree, who was stationed near the Cypress
Hills, of Superintendent Cotton, west of McLeod, of Captain C. F. Denny,
author of "The Riders of the Plains"— who performed services of special
value among the Blackfeet, Piegans, Sarcees, Stoneys and Floods—and of
Inspector Griesbach, of Fort McLeod. Minor depredations had been
committed in many places by the Indians between Calgary and Edmonton,
but happily for Canada, the Blackfeet, Piegans, Bloods, Sarcees and
Assiniboines and other warlike tribes of the Far West, decided in favour
of peace.
Having placed a small garrison at Red
Deer, and having rendered Edmonton capable of defence, Strange, on May
14th, with his depleted forces, pushed on to Victoria on the North
Saskatchewan, and thence toward Fort Pitt, in the vicinity of which Big
Bear's band was lingering. On May 24th, the day of Middleton's arrival
at Battleford, Strange passed Frog Lake, where the bodies of the victims
of the massacre were given honorable, if hasty, burial. Then the pursuit
of Big Bear's followers began in earnest. On reaching Fort Pitt, Strange
sent out in every direction scouts, including the Rev. John McDougall
and the Rev. Canon MacKay.
It may be remarked that there were five
of the MacKay brothers engaged in the suppression of the
rebellion—Thomas, a prominent member of early Territorial Councils and
Assemblies; Joseph, of the R. X. W. M. P.; James, the well-known lawyer
and member of Parliament; John and George, the missionary clergymen. All
of them were men famous for endurance, courage and skill with the rifle.
"One of them, George, a canon of the Anglican Church, accompanied our
column as chaplain," says the Presbyterian clergyman, Mr. MacBeth, who
was a member Of Strange's Winnipeg force, "and I can vouch for it that
he could fight as well as pray."
Major Steele, with his scouts operating
on the east or north side of the river, were fired upon when about ten
miles distant from Fort Pitt. Two Indians were slain in this encounter.
Meanwhile, Perry was reconnoitering south of the river. Steele presently
reported that his scouts had come upon one hundred and eighty-seven
lodges. Leaving a company of the 65th to fortify and protect what
remained of Fort Pitt, Strange, with one hundred and ninety-seven
infantry, twenty-seven cavalry and one gun, hastened to Major Steele on
the 27th. Together they advanced four and a half miles, and, coming upon
the Indians, they drove them from their position and followed them up
until darkness, approached. The 65th were hurrying after them, but
Strange and Steele could not wait for these reinforcements. Strange's
forces were obliged to bivouac that night under arms and without tents
or camp-fires. His columns at this time were really in a most hazardous
position, as is indicated by the following extract from MacBeth's
interesting reminiscences:
"Humanly speaking, I have never been
able to make out why the enemy, who were in force outnumbering us by
three to one, did not make short work of us in the darkness. The
clearing in which we were encamped was small and surrounded by dense
forest, the wagons were in zareba form, with all the men and horses
inside, and the night was intensely dark. The Indians must have been
already in panic, or, with their knowledge of the situation, they might
have rushed in, stampeded the horses, and in the confusion done serious
execution."
At dawn on the 28th, Strange moved
forward, finding numerous traces of recent trails. About 7:30 he
overtook the enemy, whom he found occupying an impregnable position in
the forks of a creek. The front and flanks of their position extended
about three miles, and were covered by a muskeg. Strange deployed his
little force, dismounted his men, and sent Major Steele forward on the
left to turn the enemy's flank, if possible. Meanwhile, a general fire
was opened all along the front. The forces under Strange's command had
been so depleted that they were now, as we have seen, considerably
outnumbered by the bands they were pursuing, and his staff pointed out
that any attempt at an actual assault upon the enemy, who were concealed
in rifle pits over the crest of the hill beyond the marsh (Frenchman's
Butte), would be exceedingly hazardous. Accordingly, after engaging the
enemy for some time, he recalled Major Steele, judging it advisable to
return to more open ground. This decision rested partly upon the
observations of Major Hatton, who could see that the Indians were moving
out towards the right, and believed that an attempt was being made to
turn Strange's right flank. Accordingly, Strange fell back six miles and
encamped, subsequently returning to Fort Pitt. During the four hours'
engagement he had but three men wounded and none killed.
It afterwards proved that Strange's
operations had been much more successful than he or his men supposed at
the time. He was unfortunately deprived of the services of Major Perry,
who was, as we have seen, absent on a reconnoitering expedition, and
would otherwise have been in charge of his gun. Consequently, it was not
at first worked to the best possible advantage and its shots went too
high.. This was noticed by Lieutenant Strange, the General's son, who
accordingly instructed the gunners to fire lower. The next shot took
effect in one of the pits, and did considerable execution. The Indians,
owing to the favorable wind, had heard Lieutenant Strange's orders, and
their prompt and sanguinary result caused a general panic and retreat,
though the Government forces were unaware of the fact. The movement,
which had been mistaken for an intended attack upon the right flank, had
been, in point of fact, the beginning of a general rout. The Indians
scattered, permitting the escape of eleven prisoners, and fell back on
Leaver River, some eighty miles distant.
"It was a pity," says General
Middleton, "that General Strange had not waited for my arrival, when a
more decisive blow might have been struck." This implied criticism is
scarcely fair, as Middleton had left Strange entirely in the dark as to
his wishes or intentions, and indeed, had not communicated with him
since May 1st.
Moreover, General Strange had notified
the Commander-in-chief of his intention of moving eastward with a view
to attacks being made upon the Indians from both directions, and he
believed the proposal had been approved. Strange now sent two plucky
volunteers, Sergeant Borrowdale and Scout Scott, down the Saskatchewan
by canoe, through the Indian country. General Middleton sent them back
with a letter to Big Bear demanding his immediate surrender, and on the
30th Middleton left Battleford with all his force, in three steamers,
with the exception of the mounted men, who came by the trail along the
south bank.
Meantime, General Strange had sent
Major Steele with cavalry to follow the trail of Big Bear's band, and
moved his own forces to Frog Lake. Major Dale, on the 2d. brought into
camp the Rev. Air. Quinney, Mrs. Quinney, Alessrs. Cameron, Ilalpin and
Dufresne, and five Halfbreed families, who had been prisoners with the
Indians. Air. MacKay, of the Hudson's Bay Company, with ten mounted men,
also recovered Mrs. Gowanlock, Mrs. Delaney and other prisoners, and
brought back to Fort Pitt, in addition to these, thirty-six members of
Big Bear's band as prisoners.
On June 4th word had been received that
Major Steele had overtaken' some of the fleeing Indians, with whom he
had had a successful skirmish at Loon Lake.
Before the battle. Steele was just
ready to offer terms of surrender.
Major Steele is confident that if the
government instead of sending up large detachments of outside forces had
simply sent in an abundance of arms and ammunition and placed the
suppression in the hands of the police and western volunteers, it would
have been brought about much more efficiently. His own men, for example,
were, after the battle of Loon Lake, reduced to fifteen rounds of
ammunition. Their supplies had been held up at Winnipeg by a customs
officer.
In the pursuit of P>ig Dear's band
through the Loon Lake country, the Canadians were hampered by the
presence of bodies of water not marked upon their maps. Nevertheless,
Steele is quite convinced that if he bad been given a freer hand and if
he had had an adequate supply of ammunition he could easily have secured
the whole band of fugitives.
On receipt of Steele's dispatch, on
June 4th, Middleton attempted to follow him up, but the country through
which the Indians were moving was characterized by such a maze of all
but impassable morasses that on the 5th he sent back the infantry. On
the same day Steele joined him. Forces under Colonel Otter from
Battleford, and Colonel Irvine from Prince Albert, were scattered north
of the Saskatchewan to prevent the retreat of the Indians, and General
Strange moved northward into the Beaver River country, where his plucky
force acquitted itself with a distinction worthy of greater recognition
than it received in some high official quarters. Says MacBeth:
"It was decided to make what became
known in the rebellion annals as 'The Silent March.' and so, leaving our
wagon train, the horses being completely tired out, we started marching
again about eight o'clock in the evening. For quite a distance our way
was through water, knee deep, and through this swamp I remember how the
Frenchmen of the 65th, almost shoeless and half clad as they were, more
than once helped the horses on Perry's gun, next to which they were
marching. It was night when we struck the heavy and practically
trackless forest, for there was scarcely any trail to be found. The
darkness grew denser as we advanced, and the great trees above us shut
out the sky. Sometimes in rank and sometimes in Indian file we kept on
marching in dead silence, with our arms ready for instant use, until
about two o'clock in the morning when a halt was ordered, and by little
twig fires—larger were not allowed—we tried to dry our wet and well-nigh
frozen garments.
"As the day began to dawn we moved on
again, and by sunrise arrived at a point near the Heaver River, where
the Indians had been seen, but found they had vanished. Evidences of
their recent presence, however, were at hand, for we found about one
hundred bags of flour cached in the woods. This was a 'windfall,' as by
this time bread was little more than a distant memory, and even 'hard
tack' was scarce enough to be appreciated."
On June 6th Strange camped near Beaver
River when an episode occurred which illustrated the spirit of his men.
"My infantry," he says, "were dead beat from marching in rain and awful
mud. The 65th, who had borne the brunt of the marching for five hundred
miles, having been in the first advance, had tramped the soles off their
boots. Some were literally bare foot, others with muddy, blood stained
rags tied around their feet. Their commanding officer told me the men
could march no more and wanted to know when they would be allowed to go
home. I outwardly thanked that officer for his information and rode up
at once to the battalion. They certainly presented a pitiable spectacle
in their tattered uniforms. The misery of their march through swamp and
forest had been added to by the mosquitoes and horse flies, which were
almost unbearable. Addressing the battalion in French, as was my habit,
I said, 'Mes enfants, votre commandant m'a dit que vous demandez quand
vous pouvez retourner cliez vous. Mais je 11'ai qn'une, reponse—e'est
celle-la de votre ancienne chanson.
'Malbrook sen va-t-en guerre.
Ne sait quand reviendra.'
It had the desired effect. The weary
little French Canadians shouted, "Huorra pour le General! En Avant!
Toujours en avant! and they stepped out to the refrain of their
ancestors."
By the 8th of June Middleton found
himself and his troops floundering through such a network of muskegs
that though it was evident he was close on the trail of Big Bear, he did
not feel justified in attempting to pursue the fugitives any further.
With Batoche captured, Riel and Pound-maker prisoners. Big Bear
powerless and a fugitive, and almost all the prisoners who had been in
the hands of the rebels again at liberty, the General felt that his work
was nearly done and commenced his arrangements for breaking up the
forces.
However, in fairness to Strange and his
officers, especially Steele and Colonel Osborne Smith of the Winnipeg
Light Infantry, the importance of the last phase of the campaign must
not be minimized. It was essential that the Indians should know that if
they violated the Queen's peace they could find no place of refuge,
however remote. These men taught them that lesson, and the task kept
them engaged weeks after most of the other members of Middleton's forces
felt that for them the war was over. One hundred picked men of the
Winnipeg Light Infantry were detached from Strange's force at Reaver
River to cross that stream and strike northward to a chain of lakes
where some of Big Bear's band had, as the issue proved, withdrawn.
MacEclh hints that the picking consisted largely of selecting those who
had some remnants of boots left, and whose uniforms could be counted on
as likely to hold together a little while longer. On June 20th scouts
from Smith's little column found the portion of the Indian band that
held Mr. McLean and other prisoners, and on the 23rd the Indians, in
response to a summons, sent them all to Fort Pitt safe and sound. They
were met on the way by Major Bedson with a detachment of the 90th.
Accordingly, Smith's adventurous One Hundred returned to the brigade,
and on July 2nd Big Bear made his way to Carlton and surrendered.
The general rejoicings over the
successful issue of the three months' campaign was tempered by the
universal regret caused by the ultimate death of Lieutenant Colonel
Williams. M. P., commander of the Midlanders, who died on board the
steamer from the effects of exposure.
Apart from the losses sustained by the
Halfbreeds and rebels, the rebellion cost Canada the lives of
thirty-nine citizen soldiers, and almost one hundred and fifteen others
had been wounded. In the general order with which Middleton took leave
of his forces, be expressed himself as follows:
"In thus completing the breaking up of
the North West Field Force, which has been under the immediate control
of Major General Middleton during the late campaign, he cannot let the
officers and men comprising it separate without expressing his great
satisfaction with them. During the whole time he has not had to assemble
one court martial; and, in fact, there has been an almost total absence
of crime. The troops have had great hardships to undergo and real
difficulties to overcome, and have borne and met them like men, with
ready cheerfulness and without complaint. They, as untried volunteer
soldiers, have had to move in a country where an extraordinary scare
existed, and against an enemy with whom it was openly prophesied they
would be unable to cope, unless with great superiority o'f numbers. The
scare they disregarded, as shown by the fact that during the whole three
months "not more than two or three false alarms took place in camp, and
the prophesy they falsified by beating back the enemy with a fighting
force equal, if not superior, to them in numbers.
Each regiment, corps, or arm of the
service has vied one against the other— and each has equally well done
its duty; not forgetting the transport service, which, under its able
officers, has so well aided our movements; the medical department, which
has been so efficiently directed, and the chaplains, who have so
carefully and assiduously ministered to our spiritual comforts.
"The Major General, in taking farewell
of his old comrades, begs to wish them all happiness and success in
their several walks of life, and to sincerely thank them, one and all,
for having, by their gallantry, good conduct, and hard work, enabled him
to carry to a successful conclusion what will probably be his last
campaign."
All Canada was justly proud of the
courage and good conduct of her citizen soldiery; nevertheless, the
pride of the thoughtful was tempered by the recollection that Duck Lake
was a decisive victory for the rebels; that at Fish Creek a handful of
men checked the advance of an army and inflicted losses double those
they sustained; that at Cut Knife Creek, Pound-maker drove back the
attacking force, which indeed owed its escape to his magnanimity; that
on the evening of the first day's fight at Batoche a dispatch seems to
have been sent calling for reinforcements from the East; that on the
second and third day of the siege Middleton failed to regain ground
occupied on the first day; that at Frenchman's Butte thc victorious
force retired from the field ignorant of its victory; and that it cost
Canada the death of some thirty-nine brave soldiers, the maiming of
approximately three times that number, and the expenditure of about
$100,000 for every Indian or Halfbreed killed in action, to crush a
rising caused by the maladministration of officials who escaped
unpunished.
Such is the story of the Saskatchewan
Rebellion of 1885. It has been necessary to omit many episodes and much
detail of a most interesting character, but so far as it goes, the
foregoing account may be accepted as fair and authentic. I have been
hampered greatly by thc gross inaccuracy of many of the official reports
and some or other features of every previous extended account of the
rising with which I am familiar. Public opinion apparently demanded a
certain style of report at the time and the demand created the supply.
After the lapse of a generation, however, it is time for a simple
statement of facts, and such I have labored earnestly to give, without
favor or prejudice. Some episodes I have deliberately omitted, however,
because not essential to an understanding of events, and because the
reverse of creditable to officials who used the distresses of their
country to selfish pecuniary advantage. Names of many of these
contemptible parasites are well known, but no good purpose would be
served by their publication at this date, to the humiliation of innocent
relatives. Let their names pass into merciful oblivion.
Mr. Thompson, in answer to Mr. Blake,
stated from his seat in the House of Commons in 1886 that the total
number of Halfbreeds committed for trial in connection with the North
West Rebellion was forty-six, Indians eighty-one and whites two.
Eighteen of the Halfbreeds were accused of treason felony, one for high
treason and one for murder. Eleven were discharged on their own
recognizance, four received sentences, eight were discharged to appear
again when called for; one, Adolph Nolin, was set at liberty on order of
General Middleton, and two others, who were held for trial, were
discharged on the proceedings being discontinued on the direction of the
Minister of Justice. Four others were also released. Of the Indians,
forty-four were convicted of various crimes, nearly all treason-felony;
one was for manslaughter, three for arson, five for horse stealing, one
for cow stealing, one for breaking goal; the others were convicted of
treason-felony. Ten were discharged on promising to come up for trial
when required. In the case of one charged with treason-felony no
evidence was elicited and he was dismissed; three were convicted. The
remainder of the Indians charged with various crimes were set at
liberty. Two who were charged with stealing were also released. Of the
whites, two were held for trial. One, W. H. Jackson, accused of
treason-felony, was acquitted on the grounds of insanity; the other, T.
Scott, accused of the same offense, was also acquitted. |