ALMOST immediately on
the passing of the Quebec Act Carleton sailed for Canada and landed on
September 18th, 1774. During his long stay in England he had married the
Lady Maria Howard, daughter of the Earl of Effingham, who with her two
children born of the marriage accompanied her husband across the
Atlantic. The lady was less than half Carleton's age, which was now
forty-eight. A family tradition attributes the fact of Carleton's
remaining so long unmarried to an early disappointment in a love affair
with his cousin, Jane Carleton. The circumstances of his marriage were
somewhat singular, and were given to me by the present representative of
the family. Lord Howard of Effingham, then a widower, was a great
personal friend of Carleton's, and of about the same age. On this
account and also foreseeing for him a distinguished career, he cordially
accepted his overtures for the hand of his eldest daughter, Lady Anne.
She and her younger sister, Lady Maria, had seen a great deal of Sir Guy
at their father's house, and doubtless regarded him as a benevolent
uncle rather than a potential lover. In time, however, they became aware
that other schemes were abroad, and on a certain occasion when Carleton
arrived at the house and was closeted with his Lordship it seems to have
been pretty well understood what he had come for. The two young ladies
were sitting together in another apartment with a relative, a Miss
Seymour, and when a message came to Lady Anne that her presence was
required by her father its purport seems to have been well known. When
this young lady returned to her friends her eyes were red from tears.
The others, waiting impatiently for her news, were the more impatient as
well as perplexed at her woe-begone appearance. "Your eyes would be
red," she replied to their queries, "if you had just had to refuse the
best man on earth."
"The more fool you,"
was the unsympathetic rejoinder of her younger sister, Lady Maria. "I
only wish he had given me the chance."
It appears that Lady
Anne was already in love with Carleton's nephew, whom she afterwards
married and who served under his uncle in Canada.
There the matter rested
for some months till Miss Seymour one day confided to Sir Guy what Lord
Howard's younger daughter had remarked on hearing of his discomfiture.
This so much interested the middle-aged lover, who, no doubt, had
recovered from a perhaps not very violent passion, that in due course he
presented himself as a suitor for the younger daughter, who proved
herself as good as her word. Miss Seymour who lived to old age used to
tell the story to members of the Dorchester family who only passed away
in comparatively recent years.
Lady Maria was small
and fair, .upright and extremely dignified, and was ceremonious to a
degree that in her old age almost amounted to eccentricity. She had been
brought up and educated at Versailles, which may be held to account for
her partiality for the French at Quebec, and may possibly have
influenced her husband in the same direction.
Soon after landing
Carleton wrote to Dartmouth, now secretary, that he found the king's
Canadian subjects impressed with the strongest sense of His Majesty's
goodness towards them in the matter of the late bill, and manifesting a
strong desire to show themselves not unworthy of the treatment accorded
to them. Events to the south, however, which were destined in great
measure to upset the governor's sanguine, and justifiably sanguine,
expectations, were hurrying forward. For while he was still upon" the
ocean the first congress had met at Philadelphia and formulated three
petitions: one to the king, another to the, British public, and that
other one to the Canadians already alluded to. Carleton had come back
armed with definite machinery for the administration of a province which
he had already handled successfully with inefficient weapons. For good
or ill the new instrument had been moulded in almost exact accordance
with his wishes. But a war cloud was now rising to the southward which
was destined for the moment completely to obscure domestic matters of a
peaceful kind. The role of wise but beneficent administrator was not yet
to be that of Carleton, who was soon to find himself committed to a life
and death struggle against desperate odds for the very possession of the
colony.
Whatever the wisdom of
the Quebec Act, as a j matter of domestic policy there is little doubt
but that it saved Canada to the British Crown, or rather enabled a
resolute commander to perform what at one time seemed a hopeless task.
The French population as a whole, it is true, quite failed to justify
the reasonable expectations formed of them. But had the Act been so
framed that their grievances were real and appealed to their enlightened
class, instead of being merely the groundless fears of a deluded
peasantry, things would have been much worse even than they were, while
a better spirit among the handful of Anglo-American traders would have
been of small account amid the clash of arms.
Almost the first
letters Carleton received after his return were from General Gage, at
Boston, requesting him to despatch there the 10th and 52nd Regiments, a
proceeding which left the governor with less than a thousand regulars in
the colony. The French subjects, however, took the earliest opportunity
of presenting addresses expressing satisfaction with the Act. Even the
British pf Quebec, in part at least, followed suit, for partisan feeling
was less bitter and pronounced there than in Montreal, whose population,
by this time numerically equal to that of the capital, showed little but
dissatisfaction. At Montreal meetings were held for the redress of*
grievances; Walker, smarting with the memory of his recent injuries,
being foremost among the firebrands, which included one Livingstone, of
the famous New York family, who had settled in the neighbourhood as a
merchant. Several of these malcontents came to Quebec, greatly to
Carleton's disgust, and successfully stimulated the less active
discontent of their co-religionists in that city. Letters of sympathy
poured in from the colonies, brought in many cases by the hand of
political agents who added their insidious eloquence to that ^ of the
local orators. Town meetings were held after the New England fashion,
while missions for fomenting discontent among the habitants were
privately organized and conducted with much assiduity under the cloak of
rural trade. Two clauses of the Quebec Act, well meant as they were,
unfortunately lent themselves somewhat readily to misrepresentation;
namely, the legalizing of the tithe or dime which u had continued by
custom rather than law since the conquest, and the retention of the old
French land laws which left to the seigniors such modified control of
their estates as they had hitherto enjoyed.
The first could without
serious mendacity be pressed home upon the habitants as a grievance. As
to the other matter it was represented that the seigniors had now
acquired more than their ancient rights and would revive the corvees and
other obsolete privileges with more than' their former vigour. The
agitators multiplied the salaries of the new officials for which the
country was to be taxed by ten and sometimes twenty-fold, and went in
and out of the thatched and whitewashed houses of the ^ peasantry under
the pretense of trade, assuring the people that they would all be
miserable slaves liable at any moment to be arrested under lettres de
cachet, and that their only hope of salvation lay in allowing the
American troops a peaceful entry into the country. The noblesse on
account of their preserved prestige, the notaries who for every reason
were attached to the French civil code, and most of the few French
bourgeoisie were practically secured to the Crown. The clergy were even
more attached to it by the late bill, and the priests, one need hardly
say, were the most formidable factor whom the emissaries of sedition
among their flocks had to encounter. Official Canada with Carleton at
its head regarded them as a bulwark of security. It was no fault of
theirs that they proved otherwise. The bounds of habitant credulity had
not yet been fathomed by the new rulers.
By November the
"ancient subjects" of Quebec had worked themselves, or been worked up,
to the delivery of a petition against the new Act, and throughout the
winter the propaganda of sedition in the country districts was conducted
with unabated zeal and remarkable effect. Dark threats were sometimes
thrown out by these emissaries of freedom against a rejection of their
gospel, and as an alternative to embracing its blessings wholesale an
army of fifty thousand men was to enter Canada and with fire and sword
lay waste the parishes from Gaspd to Montreal.
The Act was to be put
in force on May 1st, 1775. In January Carleton received a despatch
enclosing instructions and commissions from Dartmouth, who hoped that a
meeting of council might be held before the date of formal inauguration
to settle the minor offices, leaving the judicial appointments and
ecclesiastical affairs till the arrival of who was coming out, though
for a short time only, as chief-justice. Carleton writes to his
government that he has grave fears for the effect on the mind of the
peasantry caused by sedition-mongers who are moving in such numbers and
of set purpose among them. The gentry, he says, are ready enough to
serve, but do not relish commanding a militia whose spirit has so
obviously changed. As to the peasantry the government had no longer the
same hold over them as formerly, the feudal and official influence being
greatly weakened. To embody them suddenly and march them off as a
militia, even if they would march, would give colour to the stories of
impending impression so sedulously circulated by British-American
intriguers.
The Act, Carleton
intimates, was after all only a foundation for settlement; the whole
system of government had to be cast in a new form.
On May 1st, the date of
its inauguration, the kings bust in Montreal was daubed black and
decorated with a necklace of potatoes, a cross and placard bearing the
inscription, " Voila leEape du Canada et le sot Anglais". Large sums
were offered ,'for the discovery of the culprit. The French upper class
were especially indignant, one of them offering a hundred pounds for the
arrest of the offender. Personal encounters arising from the incident
took place in the streets. It was a strange situation. A clear majority
of the British residents—of whom most, it must be remembered, were of
American birth—were ripe for revolt; while every Frenchman wof the
better class was eager to serve the king. The mass of the peasantry was
supine, bewildered, suspicious, but so far as one may learn, determined
at the moment to stand aloof or to assist the rebels.
During the month of
May, 1775, news arrived in Canada that active hostilities had broken
out, Ticonderoga and Crown Point, those ancient bases of attack on
Canada, having been seized by the rebels, together with the armed craft
on Lake Champlain. Carleton in reporting it to the home government had
the melancholy consolation of referring to letters written by himself to
Gage sometime before, in which he had urged the importance of securing
these posts against all risk of surprise.
It was that rude but
vigorous Vermonter, Ethan Allen, one need hardly remind the reader, who
had accomplished this eminently serviceable but in no way perilous feat.
Ticonderoga was garrisoned by an officer and about forty, men who were;
scarcely alive to the serious state of affairs beyond the woods and
waters to the southward. It was on the night of May 10th, that Allen
with' two hundred and fifty men behind him demanded admission to the
fort, stating that he had despatches for the commandant. The guard, all
unsuspicious, and moreover acquainted with Allen, whose men were
invisible, opened the gates, whereat the Vermonters rushed in and
secured the soldiers in their beds. After this Crown Point, a few miles
away and occupied by a sergeant with half a dozen men, was summoned and
had no choice but to surrender. A large supply of cannon and ammunition
was here obtained, and the forts were occupied by provincials. The only
armed vessel on the lake was next seized and Benedict Arnold, making his
first appearance at this early stage of the war with a colonel's
commission, sailed the vessel up Lake Champlain with an accompanying
flotilla of bateaux to Fort St. Johns on the Richelieu River, twenty
miles above its outlet. The object of this visit was the capture of an
armed sloop, which Arnold brought away, together with a dozen
unsuspecting soldiers who occupied the fort.
Carleton was at Quebec
when the news of these doings arrived at Montreal by the agency of Moses
Hazen, who had been a distinguished partisan officer in the French wars
and was now farming near St. Johns. The city was stirred to a high pitch
of excitement. Colonel Templer of the 26th Regiment, to which the
captured detachments of the lake forts belonged, was in command, and at
once despatched Major Preston with one hundred and forty men of the same
corps to St. Johns which was found deserted. Allen himself had occupied
it in the interval, departing only on the approach of the British. But
for the warning of a disaffected Montreal merchant, one Bindon, Allen
and his men would probably have been cut off. By this same person Allen
sent a request for five hundred pounds worth of provisions, ammunition
and liquor to those "friendly to the cause" in the city. Bindon,
moreover, would have led Preston's detachment into an ambush but for an
accident, for which friendly intention the enraged soldiers in Montreal
seized and would have hanged the unfortunate man had it not been for the
interference of their officers.
Templer now called a
general meeting, at which it was decided that volunteers should be
raised in companies of thirty, six prominent Canadians undertaking their
formation. Fifty French-Canadian enrolled themselves at once, and
marched at Preston's request to St. Johns, which they proceeded to
occupy. Carleton, when he received the news which affirmed that there
were five hundred provincials on Lake Champlain, and one thousand five
hundred on the way there, despatched every soldier from Quebec save a
few recruits, sending them mainly to the chief point of danger and
attack, St. Johns, a poor ill-defended fort, but in a sense the key of
Canada. He himself then hurried to Montreal, and on June 7th did his
official duty, and at the same time gave vent to his personal feelings
in a letter to Dartmouth. After alluding to the events above narrated,
he proceeded to say that although the noblesse were full of zeal,
neither the peasantry nor Indians would come forward. The consternation
was universal; the province was unprepared for attack or defence; and
there were not six hundred rank and file along the whole course of the
river, nor a single armed ship. The minds of the people were poisoned
with lies, and, but for the few regular troops, three hundred rebels
might have seized all the provisions and arms in the province and kept
post at St Johns. Within the last few days, however, the Canadians and
Indians had shown signs of returning to their senses. The gentry and
clergy had been very useful, but both had lost much of their influence.
He proposed to call out the militia, hut doubted if he could succeed in
view of the seditious conduct of the British-American people in the
province, for the Habeas Corpus Act and the\ English criminal laws were
being used as arms, against the State. He expresses in this letter a
natural longing at this moment for the powers possessed in Canada by the
old governors, and finally encloses intercepted letters from Allen and
Arnold to Walker and Morrison in Montreal and to the Indians at
Caughnawaga.
Martial law was now
proclaimed and the militia called out, a severe test on the allegiance
of the reluctant habitant with the memory of the old French levies still
tolerably fresh within him. But it was Carleton's only hope, though a
slender one enough it may well have seemed, for the peasantry of the
district had not responded to the less regular but urgent call of their
seigniors and priests, and had sometimes refused with insolence. The
proclamation of martial law was fiercely opposed by the British-Canadian
Whigs, if I may so style them, with the argument that the Americans
intended to let Canada severely alone so long as she remained neutral,
but that every attempt to raise the militia would be taken as a threat
to invade the northern provinces. This would have been plausible enough
but for the fact that the Americans had secured, and were well aware of
it, the inefficiency of the Canadian rank and file even as a defensive
force and never took them into account at all as potential invaders.
Furthermore the decision to invade Canada, arrived at in the summer of
1775, was with a view to prevent the colony from becoming the base of
attack for a fresh British army, and the capture of Quebec, coupled with
wholesale promises to the Canadian peasantry in their present condition,
would have gone far towards achieving this result. Carleton at any rate
had not the slightest doubt of their intentions and in his desperate
straits had no time for the sophistries of village lawyers or partisan
pamphleteers.
Apart from all other
considerations a peremptory call to arms could not have been other than
distasteful to a rural people who had experienced more than enough of
fighting under their own monarch, when native resentment and race hatred
had been a powerful stimulant. As a further deterrent the once hated
Bastonnais were stumping through the parishes and protesting that the
measure of ease and freedom the habitant now enjoyed was slavery
compared to the Utopia they were longing to create on the banks of the
St. Lawrence. How could the simplex Canadian peasant know that the only
Utopia comprehended by the Bastonnais was one which meant the/7 probable
destruction of all the traditions, prejudices and customs that rightly
or wrongly he held dear ? It was in vain that the priests thundered from
the pulpit, that the seigniors waved their swords and that Bishop Briand
invoked their defence of their king and religion through the agency of
every parish pulpit. A few meagre companies it is true were scraped
together in the rural districts, but even these, for the most part,
melted^away through individual or wholesale desertion. As a class the
habitants turned a persistently deaf ear to priests, to seigniors, and
to officials. After all, it was a good deal to ask of a peaceful farmer
that he should leave his plough, his family and his home, and offer his
breast to bullet and bayonet in a dispute he did not understand and the
issue of which he might well believe would not materially affect him.
Both sides were foreigners and heretics and it is not difficult to
understand the sullen determination of the mass of Canadian peasantry to
leave these, mad Britons to fight out their incomprehensible quarrel
alone.
Carleton was under no
delusions, as his frequent letters to Dartmouth at this period bear
ample testimony. He had scarcely any troops and very little money and
only hoped the habitants would prove nothing worse than neutral. The
British in Montreal, as a body, refused point blank to serve. Hey,
however, who had accompanied Carleton thither, harangued them in such
scathing fashion that many were shamed into the king's service while a
few were always staunch. Guy Johnson too, nephew of the redoubtable Sir
William, arrived from the Mohawk country about this time with three
hundred of the Six Nation Indians. The Caughnawagas in similar strength
had also been attached, and a grand council was held at which their
services were accepted on the condition that they were not to fire till
first fired upon. The chief value of the Indians was for scouting
purposes, and upon this service they were soon despatched with orders to
watch the Americans at Ticonderoga.
In mid-July having done
all that was humanly possible in Montreal and leaving Colonel Prescott
in command, Carleton returned to Quebec. The Act had come into legal
force on the first of May, but practically nothing had been yet done to
get it into working order.
The notary Badeaux, who
has written an account of the invasion, tells us that at Three Rivers
the governor was entertained by Tonnancour, a wealthy Canadian trader,
money-lender, landowner and militia colonel. Perceiving an armed
Canadian promenading outside the window, Carleton inquired the cause and
was told it was a guard of honour, whereupon he at once went out to the
man and gave him a guinea as the first armed Canadian he had seen in the
district. Tonnancour's son, it may be noted, raised a company in the
locality and was very active in the British service. The same diarist
tells us that most of the parishes in the Richelieu country showed a
marked sympathy with the rebels. Some of them supplied a few men to the
militia, while from others not a single combatant could be secured.
The feelings of
Carleton as he sailed down the St. Lawrence to Quebec for the purpose of
formally inaugurating a policy of which he had formed such high hopes
may well claim our sympathy. The very people in whose interests he had
so strenuously ^ exerted himself had now turned upon him, in a negative
sense at least, and in some districts in an active one, and had
succumbed to the crafty intrigue of those who had treated them with
traditional contempt and to protect them against whom he had laboured
amid much opposition. That this was mainly due to their unexampled
credulity made the situation if anything perhaps more galling; for with
such people the secret agitator is at a marked advantage over the highly
placed proconsul, with whom truth and honour count for something, and
with Carleton they counted for much. f On his arrival at Quebec Carleton
encloses to the home government among other documents a fresh American
address of sympathy to the Canadians, commencing with characteristic
bombast: "The parent of the universe hath divided this earth among the
children of men;" also a copy of a scrap of paper thrust under the doors
of the habitants throughout the country,
i" Honi soit qui mal y
pense A lui qui ne suivra le boil chemin. "Baston."
In truth a somewhat
melancholy gathering must have been this opening of the first
legislative council under the new Act on August 17th, 1775, with so
obvious a possibility of its being the last.
Twenty-two members,
including Cramahe as lieutenant-governor, met their chief on this
depressing occasion. Eight of them were French-Canadians, for the oath
of supremacy had been remitted in favour of an oath to which Roman
Catholics could conscientiously subscribe. The oath of allegiance to the
king was followed by a clause renouncing all " equivocable mental
evasion or secret reservation." Hey, as before mentioned, was
chief-justice and among the other councillors were Saint Luc de La Corne,
de Contrecceur, Hugh Finlay, Drummond, Dr. Mabane, Pownall, Allsopp and
John Fraser. But a very few days, however, were permitted to the
peaceful labours of the council, for with the opening of September
imminent dangers from outside banished all thought of internal
legislation ; news arriving that the rebels, this time in much greater
force, had crossed the border and were again on the Richelieu. Carleton
at once hurried back to Montreal leaving Quebec of necessity as bare of
troops as ever; but Quebec for the moment was regarded as secure from
immediate danger. Instructions came from London too, about this time,
which must have provoked the much harassed governor to a bitter smile.
His Majesty, he was informed, relied on the zeal of his new Canadian
subjects, and Carleton was authorized to raise a force of six thousand
men, either to cooperate with Gage or to act independently, whichever
course should seem advisable. Arms and^ money for half the number were
already upon the sea. Whether it was a consolation to Carleton to learn
that the court of Russia had evinced a practical sympathy for His
Majesty's troubles in America, is problematical; but it was better
hearing that a corps of twenty thousand infantry had been applied for,
and that it was hoped to despatch a considerable number of them to
Canada in the spring, for Carleton held that Canada offered the best
vantage ground for overawing the provinces,—an opinion which the designs
of congress amply confirmed.
The king and his
government had all this time a pathetic, if most natural, reliance on
their much indulged Canadian subjects. As they had not even yet realized
the temper or attitude of their own people in North America the habitant
may well have remained an inscrutable item in their imperial survey.
Carleton had also secret intelligence emanating from Governor Tryon of
New York that three thousand troops from the middle and southern
colonies, to be joined by as many more from New England, were to muster
at Ticonderoga. He accordingly sent an urgent application to Gage for a
couple of regiments. The despatch arrived a few hours after Gage had
sailed for England, but Sir William Howe, now filling his place,
promptly ordered a battalion and two transports to Quebec. Graves was
then in command of the fleet and appears to have been, in spirit at
least, a survivor of the ante-Chatham period when the chief object of
the two services was to thwart each other to the utmost of their power,
for he refused the ships, under the plea that an October voyage to
Quebec was too difficult and dangerous. This was altogether too much
even for Howe, not himself distinguished for prompt action in this
lamentable struggle. But he was powerless, and could only vent his
indignation in a letter to Carleton and wish him well out of his scrape.
Carleton, though he saw
nothing before him but ruin, had at least not lost the spirit which had
early-marked him out as one of "Pitt's young men." He had now some seven
hundred troops of all ranks at Fort St. Johns under Preston, including
five hundred of the 7th and 26th Regiments, one hundred and twenty
Canadian volunteers, mostly French gentlemen, and a few artillerymen.
There were eighty regulars too at Chambly under Major Stopford, while
besides the handful at Montreal there were one hundred men of the Royal
Emigrants, largely recruited from the Highland soldiers who had settled
after the peace on the northern frontier of New York and at Murray Bay
on the lower St. Lawrence, and became afterwards the 84th Regiment. They
were raised and commanded by McLean, an able and zealous officer who did
yeoman's service throughout this whole campaign. |