DORCHESTER sailed for
England on August 18th, 1791, leaving Sir Alured Clarke, the new
lieutenant-governor, in charge. Clarke had gained some reputation in the
West Indies, and sustained it by his conduct in Canada. It was his
privilege to inaugurate the first step in constitutional government,
though perhaps of a more apparent than actual kind, the Act passing into
effect with much ceremony and festivity on December 26th. The council
remained much as before:—Chief-Justice Smith (Speaker), St. Ours,
Finlay, Baby, Dunn, DeLongueuil, Panet, Mabane, DeLevy, Harrison,
Collins, Lanaudi&re, Pownall, de Boucherville, John Fraser and Sir John
Johnson, the first eight composing the executive. The House of Assembly
did not meet till the following December, 1792, when fifty members took
their seats, two from each' district, or county. The names which Clarke
applied to these newly created countries are not felicitous.
Buckinghamshire, Hampshire, Bedford and Surrey had not been wholly
inappropriate to the broad fields of the once Church and king-loving
Anglo-Virginian squires, and, indeed, in due course acquired something
of the very atmosphere suggested by these time-honoured names. But their
sudden application to this northern land of French Catholic peasants is
something of a shock even to the reader a century afterwards, though
curiously characteristic of that inartistic side of the British
character which covered the backwoods and prairies of the United States
with embryonic classic cities. How these amazing designations fared at
the hands of the habitants we may not know—still worse even than William
Henry (vice Sorel) no doubt.
As Dorchester was
absent and my space is dwindling, I must not linger over Clarke's two
years of office; nor dwell further upon the still seething dangers of
the West, with open war raging between the Americans and Indians, and
disasters to the former, which increased his correspondence and kept him
anxious and busy. Nor is it possible /"to draw any picture of this first
mixed assembly of thirty-four French and sixteen British representatives
of the people, with the lingual and other little difficulties, the one
to be perennial, the others merely those of inexperience. It should be
noted as a social incident that Prince Edward, our late Queen's father,
arrived with his regiment, the 7th Fusileers, at Quebec just before
Dorchester left, and as a political one that Simcoe, the first
lieutenant-governor of Upper Canada, landed in November, 1791, on his
way to his official duties. His first despatches, a business at which he
was notoriously prolific, do not suggest much political acumen, for he
had formed the opinion that Hamilton was anxious for war with England,
and he did not himself think much of Washington's character. But Simcoe
was both an admirable man and a good administrator, as readers of these
volumes know.
War had been declared
by France against Great Britain and Holland some six months prior to
Dorchester's return to Canada. When he landed at Quebec, after just two
years of absence, on September 23rd, 1793, it was not before his
presence was required. A new situation had to be faced, for no one could
guess what the attitude of the French-Canadians would be when Great
Britain and their own mother country were engaged in deadly strife. That
the quarrel was with the government of the\ Revolution and not with that
of the old regime might or might not mitigate the situation. Racial
sentiment would be equally powerful in both cases, but the Church and
upper classes would have been more dangerous in the former, the
peasantry in the latter, as was soon apparent.
Quebec greeted its old
and much loved governor' with a general illumination. Bishop Jacob
Mountain, too, arrived soon after Dorchester to be the first prelate of
the Canadas, for hitherto they had been in ecclesiastical dependence on
the but little older see of Nova Scotia. Dr. Mountain had been a fellow
of Caius College, Cambridge, tutor and private secretary to Pitt, rector
of a Norwich parish, and was now to imprint his name worthily and
indelibly on Canadian records. There were now about a dozen Anglican
clergymen altogether in the two Canadas, but in Quebec neither church
nor rectory, service being still held in the chapel of the Recollets.
The crisis of the
Revolution and the fall of the French monarchy had occurred during
Dorchester's absence. The American republic was quivering with
excitement, further stimulated by French agents, and the ripples of the
tumult were being felt in the heart of the French-Canadian parishes. The
old adage that imitation is the sincerest form of flattery accounted, no
doubt, for part of this exuberance.
The wave of Gallican
sentiment that swept over the Southern and Middle States is perhaps the
most extraordinary and, in some ways, unaccountable movement in the
history of the country. Carolina, Virginia and Maryland planters whose
only acquaintance with privilege and tyranny was such as they had
themselves exercised over their own negroes—who were not, by the way,
included in this saturnalia of freedom and license—danced wildly about
crowned with caps of liberty like emancipated slaves, and exchanged the
modest courtesies of American democratic life for the fantastic
crudities of French sans-culottes.
The notorious and
impossible Genet had landed at Charleston, a few weeks before Dorchester
left England, as minister of the French republic, and executed a
triumphant overland progress to Philadelphia. The exuberant and exotic
mummery which lined the country roads and dragged the chariot of this
ridiculous Jack-in-office through the towns, brings a blush to the cheek
of the modern American as he reads of it. Never, probably, did a sane
and sensible people give way to such an exhibition of far-fetched and
misplaced banality. Jefferson pulled the strings of his puppet till the
latter's caperings broke them and left that vain and crafty demagogue
cursing his own lack of discrimination. The leaders of the Federalists
and all sensible men looked on aghast. Washington and Hamilton did more
than look on," for Genet fitted out privateers in American ports and
seized British shipping actually in American estuaries. Every one knows
how the story ended, and' how after insulting everybody all round,
Washington and even Jefferson included, this unique specimen of a
diplomat was sent about his business. Fearing to go home he became
naturalized as an American, and died in the country forty years later.
With all his feckless
effrontery, Genet had been dangerously active, during the few months he
was at large, in his endeavours to drag America into a war with England.
His agents were in every direction and were busy intriguing among the
Canadians. The French Revolution was even a better card for such men to
play than the two clauses of the Quebec Act utilized for the same
purpose in 1775. Moreover, on this occasion it was Frenchmen appealing
to Frenchmen, for many of these emissaries were Canadians who had deemed
it prudent to leave the country after the 1775-6 troubles, and had
gathered much worldly wisdom in the wider atmosphere of the American
republic. A French Utopia, where everything was to be had for the asking
and vexatious laws and burdens swept away, presented, moreover, at the
hands of a French fleet or army, was a much more alluring programme than
the more doubtful promises of the Bastonnais in 1775. France no longer
represented the very mixed blessings that its re-adoption implied in the
days of the monarchy. Seigniors, tithes, taxes, corvees and soldiering
had no place in the new order, so they were told with more grain of
truth than the Bastonnais Utopia had contained. One need not say what
the priests thought of all this, nor yet the seigniors for whom a red
republican army, even a French one, had small attraction. Some of the
notary and doctor class, themselves derived from the peasantry and from
whom alone in French Canada political adventurers could spring, seem,
however, to have regarded the new gospel with less repugnance. Besides
all this, one of the two great parties in America, that of Jefferson and
Madison, crafty and ill-balanced leaders who had never themselves smelt
powder, and the former of whom was sometimes even credited with a lack
of normal physical courage, was breathing fire and slaughter against
England and all belonging to her in senseless and suicidal fashion. The
South, as the more ignorant section, formed the main strength of their
party, while the provinces bordering on Canada supported Washington,
Hamilton and Jay in their efforts to maintain neutrality and their
predilections for Anglo-Saxon ideals with a qualified friendliness for
Great Britain.
Such was the highly
charged atmosphere in% which Dorchester once again found himself, and
now, as ever, with but a handful of troops and an unreliable militia.
One knows nothing definite of how he had passed his time in England, nor
does it signify. He kept in touch with his deputy at ' Quebec and the
British government, but otherwise, no doubt, was taking that well-earned
rest which his advancing years and his labours past and to come made
requisite; for he was now nearly seventy," and had lived a strenuous
life. He had by this time too, a large family, and so far as we know was
a domestic man with no taste for staking his patrimony at Brookes's, nor
for the deep potations of Fox and Pitt. Nor, again, had his health in
Canada been always of the best.
Prince Edward,
afterwards Duke of Kent, was still at Quebec, and remained there in
command of the 7th Regiment until the January following Dorchester's
arrival. He had made himself extremely popular with all classes, and
only left for active service in the West Indies. Kent House, above the
Montmorency Falls, still serves to remind us of a prince who is chiefly
interesting, perhaps, as Queen Victoria's father, though he has some
special claim; to notice from the fact that he held commands in British
North America for seven years, the last four of them being spent at
Halifax. Dorchester had on this occasion to reply to the many addresses
of regret at the prince's departure which reached Quebec. The latter had
left in a hurry to reach the scene of action, and while travelling on
the ice over Lake Champlain the sleighs containing all his personal
effects disappeared down an air-hole and were seen no more. At Boston we
are told he had to ship in a small vessel of six guns, which ran the
gauntlet of the French cruisers and only escaped by its fast sailing
powers, though it received their fire.
The first news
Dorchester had to send home was the failure of the peace conference
between the American commissioners and the Indians, including both those
of the West and the Six Nations, who demanded that their territory as
far as the Ohio should remain inviolate. On November 11th, he opened the
second parliament of Lower Canada, with Panet as speaker of the
assembly. He urged the necessity of passing laws for the administration
of justice, and he laid stress on the inadequate means of defence
against foreign enemies. The finances too came up, and may serve to show
the extraordinary disproportion between revenue and expenditure, so
great, indeed, as to throw four-fifths of the cost of government (which
was about twenty-five thousand pounds a year, while the revenue was only
five thousand pounds) on the Crown. This condition of things contributed
to stultify the power of the popular assembly. The veto of the uppeiN
chamber and the Crown could be exercised without any fear whatever of
consequences. The one/ effective weapon of a parliament, namely, the
withholding of supplies, was unavailable when the supplies were mainly
furnished by the British government, while in regard to the legislative
council, though its members held their seats for life, that very fact
inclined them against popular departures and to sympathy with the
governor. French influence, though not yet aggressively developed, was
naturally in the ascendant from its great numerical preponderance. Both
languagesx were used in debate, and the services of an interpreter were
regularly employed. In this first session Panet was made judge and de
Lotbiniere was chosen speaker. In November Dorchester issued a
proclamation in English and French requiring magistrates, captains of
militia, and all good subjects to seek and secure persons holding
seditious discourses, spreading false news, or publishing libellous
papers. He turned his attention also towards improving the defences of
Quebec, and passing a militia bill through the assembly.
Indeed, the military
problem was upon him again in all its seeming hopelessness, and the
dangers from within and without as imminent as ever. He issued orders
for the embodiment of two thousand militia; but though the British, who
were now more numerous than formerly, came forward "with alacrity," the
habitants objected strongly to the service. French and American
intriguers had played upon this string among others, and had succeeded
in convincing the peasantry that to be balloted as a militiaman implied
military service for life. "Nothing," writes Carleton, "is too absurd fr
them to believe." The first day they were called out to furnish their
proportion of the two thousand to be enrolled for service they broke
into a mob, and refused to be balloted for. Two were sent to prison for
riot and the country parishes threatened to rescue them.
The British proportion
of militia was only seventy out of two thousand, and this, said
Carleton, did not escape their observation.
Monk, whose voluminous
correspondence with Nepean has been preserved, speaks of the alarm
created among the merchants by Dorchester's speech in March. He, too,
tells of the general spread of French principles, and speaks of the
whole country as so infested with them that it was found on calling out
the militia that there was scarcely a hope of assistance from the new
subjects. Threats, he writes, were used by the disaffected against the
few who were found loyal. " It is astonishing to find the same savagery
exhibited here as in France in so short a period for corruption. Blood
alliances do not check the menaces upon the non-complying peasants.
These include the burning of houses, death, embowelling, decapitation
and carrying heads on poles, as the depositions show, besides throwing
off all regard for religion." The intrigues were traced to Genet and the
now numerous French consuls. Correspondence had been carried on between
Canadians in the United States and the disaffected in Canada, and French
emissaries ha< been sent in to prepare the people to follow the example
of France. Monk thought that nothingN less than five thousand troops in
Canada till the-war was ended would secure the country. An address
entitled, Les Franpais libres a leurs freres les Canadiensy was read at
a church door, and circulated as a pamphlet. In this the people were
urged to follow the example of France and the United States, and to
upset a throne so long the seat of hypocrisy and imposture, despotism,
greed, and cruelty. Their assembly is a mockery, and secret machinations
are employed everywhere to upset its efforts at better laws. Canadians,
arm yourselves, callyour friends, the Indians, to your assistance, count
on the sympathy of your neighbours and of the French." Everything in
short was to be abolished, and the habitants would find themselves in
the delightful position of an independent nation in league with France
and the United States, and would immediately rise to the blessings of
that liberal education and establish those institutions for science and
the higher arts for which they had been pining, and the free prosecution
of that ocean commerce to which their genius and inclinations were so
inclined. Even the habitant, accustomed as he must now have been to
broadsides of unintelligible bombast, must have rubbed his eyes at the
burning ambitions with which he was here credited. The prospect,
however, of getting everything for nothing was plain enough amid the
cloud of verbiage, and to an illiterate peasantry this fact has seldom
failed to appear. |