Search just our sites by using our customised site search engine

Click here to get a Printer Friendly PageSmiley

Click here to learn more about MyHeritage and get free genealogy resources

Biography of Lord Strathcona and Mount Royal
Chapter V. The Role of Peacemaker

It was at this juncture that Donald Smith came to the rescue. He had surveyed the situation from afar. Two thousand miles away, in Montreal, he pondered the matter—perceived the danger— realized the weakness of Macdougall's policy and discovered a remedy. The man for the occasion must be one who understood both sides, could deal with both, had the confidence of both and could be on the spot in person to promote a settlement. And it was in no spirit of self-esteem that he recognized in himself the man for the post. lie believed in himself. He believed that he could pacify and control the turbulent spirits, and, with no desire to exalt himself, he offered his services to the Government. He announced his intention to go to Red River to pour oil on the troubled waters of political life.

Fort Garry

What a change in his fortunes! He had spent thirty years in obscurity, living a rough and toilsome life, the companion of rough men, trading with Indians and Esquimaux, enduring physical hardships and exposed to many a hazard. His existence, so far as society was concerned and the conduct of affairs, was of the narrowest and most confined. Then suddenly he found himself in the stir and strain of public matters of the highest importance, the confidant of great statesmen and entrusted with a commission of the most delicate character. It was a tribute to the value of his experience, and to the wise use he had made of those years of discipline that, when the occasion came, he was ready to meet it. It is interesting to wonder what might have happened had he failed in the duty that was laid upon him. The whole future of the North-West and, indeed, of the young Dominion, was involved in the issue of his mission.

In order that he might be in a better position to negotiate, the authorities at Ottawa decided that he should go, not simply as an official of the Hudson Bay Company, but as "Commissioner" from the Dominion Government. To this end he received a letter from the Secretary of State, appointing him Special 'Commissioner, "to inquire into and report upon the causes, nature and extent of the obstruction offered at the Red River, etc., etc.," and also to consider and report on the most advisable mode of dealing with the Indian tribes in the North-Western Territories.

He started on his mission without delay, lie left Ottawa on the 13th of December, and travelling by rail, stage coach and sleigh, reached Pembina, on the American border, about midnight Christmas Eve. He had taken eleven days to make a journey now accomplished in one day and a half.

On the 27th of December he reached Fort Garry. There he met for the first time the so-called President, Louis Rid, who was the head and front of the rebellion, and whose reckless ambition came near to producing civil war. As he refused "to take an oath not to leave the fort that night, nor to upset the Government," Mr. Smith was kept a prisoner for nearly two months, though he was allowed considerable liberty. These two months represent a most critical period in the history of Canada. It was a trial of strength between the Canadian Commissioner and the half-breed rebel, with the advantage at the start on the side of the latter. There is no doubt that Riel was afraid of his antagonist, lie was a man of different calibre from those with whom he had had to deal, a man not easily frightened, of a powerful personal presence and also the official representative of the Dominion and Imperial Governments. After many discussions, he agreed to hold a meeting at which Mr. Smith could set forth the object of his mission and explain the intentions of the Government. This meeting was held on January 19th, 1870. It was a memorable gathering. A thousand people attended, and as there was no hail large enough to hold them, they met in the open air with the thermometer 20 below zero.

As a result of this meeting, forty representatives were afterwards elected to consider the message of Mr. Smith. Considered in the light of the subsequent history of the Canadian North-West, it is doubtful if a more important meeting was ever held. Affairs were critical. Riel and his friends were in possession and were loath to give up their position and were ready to oppose every proposal and raise every objection. Mr. Smith made a speech which was full of the wise and conciliatory spirit, he asserted that he was there in the interests of Canada, but only so far as they were in accordance with the interests of that country. He declared that so far as his connection with the Hudson Bay Company was concerned, he was ready at the moment to give up his position. lie expressed the hope that his efforts might contribute to bring about peaceably, union and entire accord among all classes of people of the country.

He then read a letter which had been written him by the Governor-General of Canada, the Hon. John Young. In that letter he was authorized to assure the people "that the imperial Government had no intention of acting otherwise, or permitting others to act otherwise, than in perfect good faith 'towards the inhabitants of the Red River district of the North-West." He was to assure them that the different religious persuasions would be respected; titles of property would be carefully guarded; existing franchises should be continued and that "right shall be done in all cases."

But the greatest impression was produced when he, in spite of the efforts of Riel to prevent it, read a communication direct from the Queen herself. There is a touch of romance in the scene— a letter from the greatest Sovereign of the age being read to a motley crowd of her subjects on that far-away prairie in the depth of winter. When the reading of this letter was finished, the assembly showed their appreciation by cheer after cheer. It is worth while to give the communication in full.

"The Queen has heard with surprise and regret that certain misguided persons have banded together to oppose by force the entry of the future Lieutenant-Governor into our territory in Red River. Her Majesty does not mistrust the loyalty of persons in that settlement, and can only ascribe to misunderstanding or misrepresentation their opposition to a change planned for their advantage. She relies on your Government to use every effort to explain whatever misunderstandings have arisen—to ascertain their wants and conciliate the good will of the people of the Red River settlement. But in the meantime, she authorizes you to signify to them the sorrow and displeasure with which she views the unreasonable and lawless proceedings that have taken place; and her expectation that if any parties have desires to express, or complaints to make, respecting their conditions and prospects, they will address themselves to the Governor-General of Canada. The Queen expects from her representative that, as he will he always ready to receive well founded grievances, so will he exercise the power and authority she entrusted to him in the support of order and the suppression of unlawful disturbances."

A "Bill of Rights" was adopted and it was decided to send delegates to Ottawa to confer with the Dominion Government. Meanwhile a Provisional Government was formed, of which Riel became President, and O'Donoghue, a Fenian priest, the Secretary of the Treasury. The next few weeks were marked by stormy episodes. Six hundred men marched on Fort Garry to secure the release of the prisoners confined there. On the approach of this force, Riel set the prisoners free, but revealed his treacherous nature by arresting nearly 50 of the rescuers as, after the matter was settled, they were returning to their homes. Among these was Major Boulton, whom he condemned to be shot, but was persuaded by the earnest efforts of Mr. Smith to recall the sentence and set him free. In the case of Thomas Scott, however, the result was more dreadful. Ile was one of the prisoners and for reasons that seem altogether insufficient was condemned to death. In vain Mr. Smith and others interceded for him. The President was immovable in his determination, and early in March the young man was put to death.

Return to Book Index Page

This comment system requires you to be logged in through either a Disqus account or an account you already have with Google, Twitter, Facebook or Yahoo. In the event you don't have an account with any of these companies then you can create an account with Disqus. All comments are moderated so they won't display until the moderator has approved your comment.