THE British North
America Act, by which the provinces of Upper and Lower Canada, New
Brunswick and Nova Scotia were bound into a confederation, came into
force by royal proclamation on the first day of July, 1867. When it is
considered how vast and vital a change this measure brought about, it is
surprising that it produced so little excitement anywhere. With the
exception of one or two demonstrations which were made with flags by
persons hostile to confederation, it was received in the province of New
Brunswick, which had been so much excited during two elections, with
perfect calmness, and although for some years afterwards there were
always a number of persons opposed to union who predicted direful things
from confederation, and thought it must finally be dissolved, the voices
of such persons were eventually silenced either by death or by their
acquiescence in the situation. To-day it may be safely declared that the
Canadian confederation stands upon as secure a foundation as any other
government in the civilized world.
In June, 1867, the Hon.
John A. Macdonald, the leading spirit in the government of Canada, was
intrusted by Lord Monck, then governor-general, with the formation of a
ministry for the Dominion. Mr. Macdonald naturally experienced a good
deal of difficulty in making his arrangements. In the formation of the
first ministry much care was necessary; provincial and national
interests were to be thought of and denominational claims had to receive
some attention. But the greatest difficulty arose with respect to old
party lines. Mr. Macdonald thought that these ought, as far as possible,
to be ignored, and accordingly selected his men from the leading
advocates of confederation belonging to both parties, placing in his
cabinet seven Conservatives and six Liberals. The Liberals included the
names of Mr. W. P. Howland and Mr. William MacDougall for Ontario. A
large number of the Liberals of Ontario, including George Brown and
Alexander Mackenzie, opposed this arrangement, called a public meeting
in Toronto, and passed resolutions in favour of a strictly party
government on the old lines. It declared hostility to the proposal for a
coalition, and resolved to oppose Messrs. Howland and MacDougall, should
they accept office under Mr. Macdonald. This decision was carried out,
but these gentlemen were both elected by good majorities. In this first
ministry there were five members from Ontario, four from Quebec, two
from Nova Scotia, and two from New Brunswick: S. L. Tilley and Peter
Mitchell.
The wisdom of the
course adopted will be apparent when it is remembered that the question
of confederation was not settled or carried on party lines, some of the
Conservatives opposing and some Liberals supporting it. This was clearly
the case in New Brunswick, as shown by the last two elections held
there. About one-third of the Liberal party, and a like proportion of
the Conservative party, opposed confederation at the second election. To
have formed the first government on a party basis would have
necessitated the selection of some men who were opposed to the union,
and whose efforts might not have been devoted to making it a success.
The first confederation
ministry was a very strong one. The Hon. John A. Macdonald became
premier and minister of justice; the Hon. George E. Cartier was minister
of militia and defence; Alexander T. Galt was minister of finance; the
Hon. William MacDougall was minister of public works; the Hon. W. P.
Howland was minister of inland revenue; the Hon. A. J. F. Blair,
president of the privy council; the Hon. Alexander Campbell,
postmaster-general; the Hon. J. C. Chapais, minister of agriculture; the
Hon. Hector L. Lan-gevin, secretary of state. The Hon. Mr. Tilley became
minister of customs and the Hon. Mr. Mitchell minister of marine and
fisheries, while the two Nova Scotia representatives, Messrs. Archibald
and Kenny, became respectively secretary of state for the provinces and
receiver-general.
It will thus be seen
that the Maritime Provinces had four representatives out of thirteen
members of the cabinet, and this proportion has generally been
maintained since that time; so that the fears of those who anticipated
that the provinces by the sea would not receive fair treatment in the
distribution of high offices have proved to be groundless. On the
contrary, it can be said that the Maritime Province members of the
government appear always to have occupied a very influential position.
The office of minister
of customs, which Mr. Tilley received, was thought by some of his
friends to be less important than he deserved, they being of the opinion
that he should have been made minister of finance. This office, however,
went to Mr. Galt, who, owing to a difference with the rest of the
government, resigned four months later, his place in the cabinet being
taken by Sir John Rose, who held the office of finance minister until
October, 1869, Sir Francis Hincks then receiving the appointment. It was
not until the resignation of the latter in February, 1873, that Mr.
Tilley became minister of finance. The office at first assigned to him,
however, was one of great importance, involving as it did the
reorganization of the entire establishment of the customs of Canada, and
it gave ample scope for his great ability as a business man.
The elections for the
House of Commons in the new parliament of Canada took place in August,
when Tilley was chosen to represent the city of St. John, and John H,
Gray, the county. It had been expected, in view of the fact that these
men had been so largely instrumental in bringing about confederation,
that they would be allowed to walk over the course unopposed. This was
the case with Mr. Gray, whose candidature met with no opposition; but
Mr. Tilley was opposed by Mr. John Wilson, who received a very small
vote. This needless and futile opposition to the candidature of a man
who deserved so well from the province, was merely one of the proofs of
the existence of political rancour in the breasts of those who had been
defeated on the confederation question.
The first parliament of
united Canada met on November 6th, 1867, and the address was moved by
the Hon. Charles Fisher, who had been elected to represent the county of
York. The session was a very long one, lasting until May 22nd of the
following year; but there was an adjournment, extending from December
21st to March 20th. This meeting of parliament was especially memorable,
inasmuch as it brought together, for the first time, the representatives
of all the provinces, and the ablest men of all political parties. The
people of Ontario and Quebec were little known to the people of the
Maritime Provinces, and those who resided in the larger provinces in
like manner knew comparatively little of their fellow-subjects who dwelt
by the sea. It was expected by some that the Maritime Province
representatives would be completely overshadowed by men of greater
political reputation belonging to the larger provinces, but this did not
prove to be the case. The Maritime representatives at once took a
leading position in parliament, and this position they have steadily
maintained down to the present time. No man stood better in the House of
Commons than the representative from St. John, the Hon. S. L. Tilley.
At, that time Her Majesty, the Queen, in acknowledgment of his services
in the cause of confederation, had created him a .Companion of the Bath,
a distinction which was also given to the Hon. Charles Tupper, of Nova
Scotia.
A vast amount of
business had to be disposed of at the first, session of the parliament
of Canada. Although the Union Act embodied the plan upon which
confederation was founded, it was necessary to supplement it by a great
deal of special legislation, for the purpose of interpreting it and
making preparations for the practical working of the constitution. In
all the discussions relative to the measures which had to be passed at
that time, Tilley took a prominent part, and, when the session was over,
he had established in the House of Commons, as fully as he had in the
legislature of New Brunswick, a reputation for ability as a speaker and
as a man of affairs. He was looked upon as one whose wide knowledge of
the needs of the province and whose experience in departmental work were
likely to be of the greatest use to the confederation. His high
character gave weight at all times to his words, and caused him to be
listened to with the most respectful attention. During the whole period
that Tilley sat in the House of Commons, he had the pleasure of knowing
that even his political enemies respected his character and abilities,
and, with the exception of the premier, perhaps no man wielded a more
potent influence in the councils of the Dominion than he.
It is not necessary
here to trace to any large extent the career of Sir S. L. Tilley in the
parliament of Canada; that belongs rather to the history of the Dominion
than to a work which deals particularly with his connection with his
native province. Only so much of his public life in the House of Commons
will be dealt with as seems necessary to complete his personal history.
Tilley continued to hold the position of minister of customs during the
whole of the term of the first parliament of Canada. This parliament
held five sessions and dissolved in the summer of 1872, the general
election being in the month of July, upon which occasion he was
reelected for the eity of St. John without opposition.
The second parliament
met on March 5th, 1873. Eleven days before that time Mr. Tilley had'
become minister of finance, succeeding Sir Francis Hincks, who had
resigned that office after holding it for more than three years. The
advancement of Mr. Tilley to this responsible and influential position
was very pleasing to his friends, and was received with satisfaction by
the country generally.
The first confederation
ministry of Canada resigned office on November 5th, 1873, under
circumstances which are a part of the political history of the Dominion
and need not be gone into in this volume, further than to say that,
whatever basis there may have been for charges of corruption in
connection with the Pacific Railway contract against other persons in
the government, none were ever preferred against Mr. Tilley; nor' did
any one suspect or believe that he had anything whatever to do with the
transactions which led to the resignation of the government. Prior to
that event Mr. Tilley had been appointed lieutenant-governor of the
province of New Brunswick in succession to the Hon. Lemuel A. Wilmot,
whose term had expired. Every one felt that the honour thus bestowed
upon Tilley was a most fitting one, for he was New Brunswick’s foremost
son in political life, and had reached his high position purely through
his own ability and his own good character. That position he filled a
greater number of years than any of his successors are likely to do, and
it is admitted on all sides that no man could have performed the duties
of the office more satisfactorily than he did. |