Editor's Preface
ALEXANDER HENRY THE
YOUNGER, whose Journal of 1799-1814 forms the main body of the present work,
is a person of whom hardly anything has been known hitherto, and one who
therefore requires formal introduction to the readers he may reasonably hope
to win on this, his first appearance in public, as an autobiographer.
The author of Henry's
Journal must not be confounded with that other Alexander Henry—the Elder, as
the latter may be called, now that there are two writers of the identical
name—whose well-known Travels and Adventures in Canada and the Indian
Territories between the Years 1760 and 1776 was published at New York by I.
Riley in 1809, and who died at Montreal April 14th, 1824: see Canadian
Magazine and Literary Repository, Vol. II., Nos. 10 and II, April and May,
1824, for biographical data. The two men were related as nephew and uncle,
and led similar lives in like scenes under identical occupations ; but their
respective narrations have no connection with each other. Like his elder
relative, the younger Henry was a fur trader among the American Indians; and
during the period over which his Journal extends he was one of the famous "Northmen,"
as they used to be called—that is, one of the partners in the celebrated old
Northwest Company of commercial adventurers, whose restless activities and
indomitable energies covered a continent with the most formidable rivals the
Hudson Bay Company ever encountered. The annals of American adventure may be
searched in vain for more picturesque pages than those inscribed with the
daring and thrilling exploitations of these pioneers in penetrating and
occupying the vast region which may be styled the "Greater Northwest."
The most commanding figure among the Northmen is Sir
Alexander McKenzie, whose double laurels are those of first reaching the
Arctic ocean by way of the great river which still bears his name, and of
first reaching the Pacific ocean overland through British America ; and
whose work, originally published in 1801, has become classic. In that year
our untitled Alexander Henry was established as a winterer or hivernant in a
post he had built on the Red River of the North, and engaged in the humble
routine of traffic with the Indians, whom he cheated and debauched as a
matter of course, with assiduity and success, upon strict business
principles and after the most approved methods. Meanwhile, however, he fell
into another habit, of which the Northmen were seldom guilty; for he took to
the pen, and at his leisure—that is, when he was not serving his coppery
customers with diluted alcohol or other articles they desired to secure at
fabulous prices—he kept a journal. In this literary habit he persevered
until the very day before his death; and this veracious chronicle, in which
nothing whatever is extenuated, for aught there be set down in malice, is
now before us. It may not be of the heroic order; but it mirrors life in a
way Mr. Samuel Pepys might envy, could he compare his inimitable Diary with
this curious companion-piece of causerie, and perceive that he who goes over
the sea may change his sky, but not his mind. There is said to be a great
deal of human nature in mankind; certainly our author had his share of it,
and so had all the people in his book, to judge from the way that English,
Scotch, French, American, and Indian characters are shown up under his
unterrified hand.
In the course of the fifteen years during which Henry's
journalistic devotion is witnessed in these pages he traveled from Lake
Superior to the Pacific, with protracted intervals of residence at various
points in his long voyaging. His commercial ventures
caused adventures through the Provinces of Ontario,
Manitoba, Assiniboia, Keewatin, Saskatchewan,
Alberta, and British Columbia,
in the present Dominion of
Canada ; and, in the United
States, through Wisconsin, Minnesota, North Dakota,
Idaho, Oregon, and Washington. In the region of the
Red river his dealings were with Ojibways and other
Indians of Algonquian lineage, whilst his warrings
were with Sioux ; along the Saskatchewan he trafficked
with Crees, with Assiniboines,
with Blackfeet, Bloods, Piegans,
Atsinas, and some of the Athapascan tribes,
especially Sarcees ; on Columbian waters his commerce
was with Chinooks, Clatsops, and many other
aborigines of the Pacific slope.
He was once on terms with the Mandans and their associates of
the Missouri, and visited
the Cheyennes in their company. So far from being
peculiar to Henry's case was
such an extensive acquaintance with
Indians, this was the common fortune of the
Northmen ; but few of them have recorded
their experiences, for the gun
was oftener than the pen in the hands
of even those whose souls soared above
a beaver-skin. An always sordid
and not seldom nefarious environment, during dreary
months of isolation and desolation,
alternating with periodical peregrinations of
immense extent and arduousness— conditions
of extreme personal peril from hunger, cold, and
savagery—experiences whose deadening monotony was modified mainly by
deadlier danger—such are not
circumstances conducive to literary accomplishment. An
Irving's easy-chair is an easier
way of wooing the muse to exploit
the romance of Northman or
Southman, and the world applauds an Astoria.
But what of the actors
themselves in such stern realities, whose glamourless
lives, as a rule, survived illusions only
to find oblivion their finality?
When one of these speaks for
himself, we can but listen to his words ; the
world is never too busy to hear a
genuine adventurer's own story of his
adventures. So it happens that—to
mention a few of those whose works in this special
field of fur-trade literature do
follow and live after them—McKenzie is
perennial ; so are Samuel Hearne, Edouard
Umfreville, Arthur Dobbs, Alexander Henry the
Elder, Daniel Williams Harmon, Gabriel Franchere, Ross
Cox, Alexander Ross, John Tanner. Among these worthies, and with others who
could be named, all of them closely
connected with our author, some
of them his personal associates, Alexander
Henry the Younger has hitherto failed
to stand, not because he was no author, but
simply because his work was born out of time and long
seemed to have perished with him.
Henry's Journal has slept for
nearly a century, during which his
memory has been almost effaced. But I think it will now take its
rightful place among the most important contributions
ever made to the inside history of
the fur trade in British
America in general, and of the
Northwest Company in particular—even McKenzie's
hitherto unrivaled work may need to
look to its laurels. Henry the Elder having
been one of the first whites who penetrated
to the plains of the
Saskatchewan, after the French regime and before
there was any Northwest Company, it is fitting
that another of the same name,
Alexander Henry the Younger, should take up the theme, and bring the same
subject down nearly to the
close of the Northmen's organized
existence. The thread of his narration would
doubtless have been spun to the end of
that organization, had it not fallen short
through the shears of inflexible Atropos.
The fact that, as already
intimated, Henry's invaluable
Journal has never before seen the light, would surprise
no judge of literary material who should
inspect the manuscript which has
served as the basis of the
present work. No printer could handle the copy
as it stands; no publisher would be justified in
undertaking to bring it out; and the task
of redaction was clearly one
which called for a combination of
hardihood and hard work from which any editor
might well shrink, hopeless of
successful accomplishment. Piqued, perhaps, by the
latent possibilities of this case, stimulated
to the endeavor by a very
genuine interest in all that relates to the history of
American pioneering, and observing that the Henry period was precisely the
one with which I had become most familiar in consequence of similar work
done in other connections, I undertook to shape Henry's Journal for
presentation to the public. It is not for me to say anything of the merit or
demerit of my own performance ; but the manuscripts upon which I worked are
so nearly unknown that an account of them becomes a bibliographical
necessity.
Of Henry's original notebooks or diaries, penned manusua,
I know nothing—not even whether or no they be still extant; I have never
seen his handwriting, even to the extent of his signature. Henry's Journal,
as we have it, is what is known as "the Coventry copy," mafiu aliena, penned
by George Coventry, about the year 1824; for the date "Montreal, February
20th, 1824," is set as a sort of colophon at the end. This writing is
furnished with a formal title-page, worded "Journal of Alexander Henry,
Esq.," and so forth, and signed "George Coventry." A page of "Preliminary
Remarks" speaks of Mr. Henry in the third person, and notes his decease. The
whole copy makes ostensibly 1,642 pages, as per pagination of the folios;
the paper is of legal cap size, rather larger than is now usual, written for
the most part on both sides of the sheets, and bound in two thick volumes
now preserved in the Library of Parliament at Ottawa. By the ofificial
permission of the authorities, courteously granted at my request, and by
business arrangements made by my publisher with Mr. L. P. Sylvain, the
assistant librarian, I obtained a clerical copy of the whole of this
manuscript, folio for folio, with the exception of certain insignificant
portions, notably meteorological tables, which I did not care to use. The
manuscript which I received is duly certified by Mr. Sylvain to be literally
true to copy; and great care was taken to produce a faithful transcript.
The identification and authenticity of the Coventry copy
are established beyond peradventure of a doubt. We can also settle the
question which may arise in some minds whether these manuscripts represent
exactly what Henry himself wrote, or are what Mr. Coventry wrote out for
him, from original memoranda. The Coventry documents attest their own
genuineness by internal evidence which enables us to form a safe and sure
conclusion. Thus, for instance: as explained in a note on my printed p. 747,
certain folios of the manuscript retraverse identical dates, with
duplication in substance of what is said, but in an entirely different style
of composition. One of these duplicates agrees in every peculiarity of
locution with the main body of the writing, and is thus presumptively
Henry's own. The replica, which is obviously not Henry's, but Coventry's
own, is of the nature of editorial rewriting, and agrees exactly with
certain other writings known to be Coventry's, who must have been intending,
when he penned these passages, to edit his Henry materials for publication
—as the replica is fitted with chapter heads, furnished with something in
the nature of a preface, and adorned with religious reflections on the
goodness of God in drowning so estimable a man as Mr. Henry—in fine, it is
editorially dressed for the press. None of this matter has proven available
for my own purposes, and none of it has been used ; but its existence is a
boon, as it enables us to decide that the main body of this writing is a
faithful and wellintended transcript of Henry's own Journal, made by one so
profoundly ignorant of the whole subject of which it treats that he could
hardly do anything else than copy what he found, in the most servile and
wooden-headed manner imaginable; in other words, he did not know enough of
what he was about to make other than clerical errors, and therefore could
have manufactured nothing.
But the comforting assurance I felt, in handling these
documents, that I had to do with genuine as well as authentic materials, in
substance and practically in form Henry's own, did not resolve my fears
regarding the outcome of my editorial enterprise. To begin with, there was
too much copy for a book of reasonable dimensions; it needed to be "boiled
down " by at least one-third. In the second place, Henry in his writing used
language such as no fur trader ever spoke—nor anyone else, unless English be
indeed a grammarless tongue; for solecism seldom failed to supersede syntax
in his maze of verbiage, and sense was always liable to be lost in a
wilderness of words. The composition seemed to me to be that of a man who
knew what he wanted to say, and could talk to the point about it, but always
wrote round about it, as if he had a notion that writing was something
different from speaking, needing bigger words and more of them. Thus, our
author went all over the country, but always "proceeded" in his Journal. He
saw a great deal, in fact, but never failed to "perceive" or "observe" it
when he wrote about it; and whenever he had to get ready to go somewhere, he
was likely to write: "I now once more found myself again under the necessity
of being obliged to commence preparing for my intended departure
immediately." Imagining that few readers would have the patience to follow
him to the end of journeys begun in that fashion, I concluded to take what
grammatical liberties with the manuscript I saw fit. Deletion of simply
superfluous words, and of sheerly tautological phrases, made it shrink about
one-fourth, with corresponding increase in tensile strength of fiber.
Another revision, in the course of which almost every sentence was recast in
favor of such grammatical propriety as could be impressed upon the
composition without entirely rewriting it, reduced the copy to about
two-thirds of its original dimension; and the upshot of all this "blue
penciling " was a textual compromise between what I had found written and
what I might have preferred to write, had the composition been my own.
Literary elegance being clearly out of the question, however cunningly I
might put in any little dabs and touches, I was perforce satisfied to make
my author say what he meant to say in plain English, letting him go on with
equal pace to the massacre of his mother-in-law or the setting of his yellow
hen on thirteen eggs. Closely as the composition may resemble a schoolboy's,
the literalism is that of a mature mind. Henry took himself very seriously
indeed, and we must take him at the foot of the letter.
The foregoing explanation, in the nature of semi-apology
for the liberty I have taken with historical documents, will not be deemed
superfluous if it serves to satisfy the mind of any would-be critic who, on
comparing my printed pages with the manuscript in the Library of Parliament,
observes with surprise or regret their wide discrepancy in language. I do
not pretend to have printed that manuscript. On the contrary, I have used it
as material to be worked up ; and I have yet to state what further
compression of the bulk of the original was required, and has been effected,
to bring the whole within a desired compass. For I have condensed to the
utmost some parts of the Journal, and even have canceled certain entries of
little or no present significance. Such extremely condensed or omitted
passages relate chiefly to trivial incidents of trade so much alike that one
samples the whole, and incessant repetition would be tiresome ; to details
of game killed for the support of the posts; and to weather-reports. Even
the most modern meteorological tables interest few persons, and I suppose
none now care much about the weather as it was a hundred years ago. Yet I
have set myself bounds against transgressing upon my author in this
particular, for everything about the weather that seemed to bear upon the
thread of his narrative, as affecting his movements, as influencing the
fauna or flora, as touching acceleration or retardation of- the seasons, has
been piously preserved. Despite the very great reduction and other
modification to which the manuscript has necessarily been subjected in
passing through my hands, I do not think that I have omitted or obscured a
single matter of fact of the slightest significance, or subordinated the
author's individuality to my own. I have simply caused him to tell his own
story as plainly as he evidently wished to tell it, and supposed that he was
telling it ; and no doubt the resulting picture is all the clearer for the
polishing, I can vouch for its inviolate fidelity to fact throughout. The
trader and traveler can be followed with perfect confidence across the
continent. There is not, to my knowledge, a single statement in the book
that can be seriously questioned on the score of veracity. Devoid as he was
of certain accomplishments desirable in one who aspires to authorship, and
writing as he did for no eye but his own, Henry certainly produced a
remarkable work, of solid and permanent value. It is one which should have
appeared long ago, and taken its rightful place in contemporaneous
literature.
Thus far in explanation of my connection with this work I
have appeared simply as my author's literary censor — mainly in mere matters
of grammar, but also with some further privileges of the blue pencil. But
more agreeable and significant functions than those of the schoolmaster
abroad attach to my editorial work in the present instance; and how I have
tried to do my whole duty as a critic and commentator remains to be said.
Intending to interpret Henry to a generation remote from his own, and
remembering the measure of success attained in the similar cases of Lewis
and Clark, and of Pike, respectively—for these American explorers were
Henry's contemporaries, who cultivated in the United States a field of
adventure which may be compared with that occupied by Henry in the British
possessions—I undertook to put upon Henry's Journal an extensive critical
commentary, from the standpoint of our present knowledge.
This seemed even more desirable in the present case than
in those of the American explorers just named, inasmuch as e was unknown,
they were famous; inasmuch as his work had never appeared, while theirs had
already passed through many editiors; and I should therefore be plowing
virgin ground instead of formerly cultivated soil that had long lain fallow.
Satisfactory equipment for this undertaking could only be acquired by going
over the whole field historically. At the conclusion of protracted and
diligent study I found myself in the possession of some 4,500 memorandum
cards, alphabetically arranged by subjects, and collectively constituting a
sort of private cyclopedia of information concerning the Northwest Company,
the X. Y. Company, the fur trade of those days, the bourgeois, their
voyageurs and other engages, their Indian customers, their trading-posts,
their canoe-routes—and what not in the way of biography, geography,
ethnography, and natural history. Most of this material was found to fit in
with Henry's narrative to a nicety; and even the residuum, touching points
which Henry did not happen to bring up, was available for incorporation
alphabetically in the Index to the work. Most of my information was drawn
afresh from its original sources; but I also utilized the labors of modern
historical authorities, such as Masson and Tasse, each of whom has recently
given us an invaluable work upon subjects germane to our present enterprise.
It is not probable that the name of any person, either of the Northwest or
of the X. Y. Company, which appears in either of these authors, has escaped
me, and it is certain that many more than have ever appeared in print before
are given in the present work; so that the result, in this one biographical
particular, represents a closer approach to a complete gazetteer of the
personnel of the two companies, from the humblest of their engages to the
most redoubtable leaders of those great enterprises, than has hitherto been
given to the public. The difficulty of identifying personal names in these
old records is well known to be very great, for various reasons; most of
those concerned in these affairs were obscure individuals, whose memory is
now but a name, oftentimes so unsettled in orthography that a dream of the
shadow of smoke were scarcely more elusive; and in the records which reach
us, furthermore, it is often only a surname that appears, though it may have
been, and usually was, borne by several different persons. I have taken the
utmost pains in this particular; but I am sure that in my notes, as well as
in Henry's text, different individuals are sometimes confounded under the
same name, and again, that the same person figures in some cases as two or
more, under various versions of his proper name, to say nothing of nicknames
or aliases. Yet I suspect that the alphabetical list of personal names which
appear in my Index is at once the most extensive and the least faulty that
has ever been published—though far from completion or perfection it
certainly is.
To turn from biographical to geographical considerations,
I may next allude to the great care I have exercised in identifying the
localities named in Henry's travel or residence, and in giving the modern
equivalents of the mostly obsolete nomenclature he uses. His list of
place-names is remarkably interesting, the designations then in vogue being
dominated by the influence of the earlier French regime, which continues to
be felt to the present day, though of course less markedly than it was in
his time. No Fort des Prairies now exists by such name, but the thing still
flourishes in the shape of the H. B. Company's store at Edmonton, and the
very gradual process of supplanting the old French terminology will probably
never be quite completed. Geographical synonymy is a subject which for many
years has occupied my attention; it is a field more fruitful of historical
data than most persons would suppose, and one which has never been
thoroughly worked out for any considerable area of Western or Northwestern
America. The trouble seems to be that the best geographers have seldom been
historians, while historians so good that they would blush to be caught
afoul of a date wrong by a day are often found miles out of the way in the
location of their events. Henry was no geographer, in a technical sense, and
not much of an explorer, even; he never traveled for health or pleasure, but
always on business, and made no actual discoveries. Yet he was a great
traveler, who covered an immense area both by land and water, with a good
eye for topography en route; he was also well able to say where he went and
how he got there. Consequently, I have found little difficulty in trailing
him through all the intricacies of his canoe-routes—that wonderful system of
waterways, the like of which may be looked for rather in 'the myth of the
Daedalian labyrinth than in the geography of any country but that which he
traversed—over the limitless prairie of a Dakota, even into the treacherous
sphagnum of a muskeg. Henry is not quite so easy to trail as Lewis and Clark
are, but he is easier by far to follow than Pike, for example; and any knack
of going by "sign" I may have acquired by former experiences has stood me in
good stead in the present case. Henry's routes may be recovered with almost
absolute precision, and he made few camps in all his journeyings that I
cannot now set with hardly any probable error.
Few men who have ever put pen to ethnographical paper
have had more extensive, varied, and intimate personal acquaintance than
Henry acquired with Indians in the course of his long experiences as a
trader among many different tribes of distinct linguistic stocks, from the
Algonquians and Siouans of his earlier experiences, through others of the
Saskatchewan and Missouri, to the many different Pacific families he finally
met. Intimately connected with his customers as he was, thoroughly versed in
their characters, habits, and manners as he became, he had no sympathy with
them whatever. They were simply the necessary nuisances of his business,
against whom his antipathies were continually excited and not seldom
betrayed in his narrative. He detested an Indian as much as he despised a
Franco-Canadian voyageur, or hated a rival of the H. B. or X. Y. Company.
How much of "sweetness and light" is likely to seep and shine through the
private pages of a man whose prejudices were invincible and sometimes
violent, of one who was quite out of touch with his own environment, the
reader may judge for himself ; as he may also observe how chary and wary I
have been, as a rule, in expressing any opinion of the moral of a story
which shows up the seamy side of things so persistently and sometimes so
obtrusively. That is no metier of mine—who am I, that I should set up to
keep my brother's conscience ? I have left the risque passages much as they
stand in copy, only Bowdlerizing some expressions that were doubtless
current in the blunt speech of the trading-post, but would hardly bear print
now. The book is not virginibus puerisque, and I suppose few such, if any,
will ever read it. Aside from any question of chaste taste, which after all
belongs in the background of historical relations like the present, and need
agitate no one unduly, I am persuaded that Henry's disillusionment, his
practical pessimism, his entire lack of imagination, and his insistence upon
bare fact through sheer infertility of invention, have conspired to a
singularly veracious contribution to ethnology in all that he has to say of
his Indians. They are the genuine aboriginal articles, not the mock heroes
of Leatherstocking romance. Henry's is an absolutely unvarnished tale, in
which no question of a fig-leaf is raised, for the reason that his Indians
wear their breech-clouts or leave them off according to their own
convenience, without regard to our own ideas of propriety. I could add
nothing to such a picture as this, and would not if I could; should anyone
desire a revelation of almost inconceivable and quite unspeakable nastiness,
let him read, for example, the transparent pages of Samuel Hearne, and see
how completely they corroborate Henry, as far as the latter goes — for he
leaves unsaid much more than Hearne does; but with the impersonal and purely
ethnic aspects of this case I have dealt from the standpoint of to-day, in
giving the accepted classification and nomenclature of all the Indian tribes
and linguistic families of which our author treats.
Henry was familiar, of course, with all the animals whose
furs or pelts had any commercial value, or whose flesh was staple of food ;
but he was no naturalist, and there is little natural history in his book,
aside from his extremely interesting accounts of the buffalo and other large
game. In zoology and botany, therefore, there was little for me to do; but I
have identified and supplied the technical names of nearly all the animals
and plants mentioned in his narrative.
No account of my connection with this work would approach
desirable completeness did I not speak emphatically of the use I have made
for the present purpose of the original manuscripts of DAVID THOMPSON, the
celebrated astronomer, geographer, explorer, and discoverer—in a word, the
scientist—first of the Hudson Bay Company, then, during the whole period
covered by Henry, of the Northwest Company, and later still of the
International Boundary Commission which ran the line between the British
possessions and the United States. I have so effectually bound up Thompson's
life-work in the Greater Northwest with that of Henry, that he becomes
virtually co-author of the present publication, upon the title-page of which
his name appears in simple justice to his share of the performance — albeit
the main text consists solely of Henry's Journal, Thompson's contributions
being, like my own, confined to the foot-notes.
The original Thompson documents, in his own handwriting,
are preserved intact in the archives of the Surveys Branch of the Crown
Lands Department of Ontario, at Toronto, where I was courteously given free
access to and use of them, at different times in 1894 and 1895, by official
vote of the members of the Cabinet of the Ontario Legislature. The whole
span of these precious records is from 1784 to 1850, as represented by the
extreme dates of the successive entries in the series of about 40 volumes,
mostly of foolscap size, and for the most part averaging, perhaps, 100 pages
to a volume; besides which there are sundry unbound pieces—I made a minute
analysis of the whole, as a bibliographer, but that need not now detain us.
There is also one very large map, manu sua, covering the region from
the Great Lakes to the Pacific. Some of the most important volumes relate to
Thompson's life after 1812, when he was engaged in highly responsible
professional duties upon the Boundary Survey just named; but with these we
have no present concern. Thompson's intimate connection with the scenes of
Henry's Journal was in earlier years, say 1789-1812, during which he
antedated or codated Henry on every one of the routes which the latter ever
pursued. The Henry and Thompson trails, so far as the former's extend, are
thus conterminous, and to some extent coincident in dates. Finding frequent
mention of Thompson by Henry, I recognized the close relation of much of the
Thompson manuscript with the whole of Henry's, and consequently made a
careful study of the former in connection with the latter. Thompson's
records from the winter of 1789-90, when he was at Cumberland House on the
Saskatchewan, to Aug. 12th, 1812, when he left Fort William on Lake Superior
for Montreal, thus ending forever his explorations in the Greater Northwest,
are voluminous and almost complete; there is hardly a break in the
day-by-day entries for these 23 years, and even in the few instances where
the diary is interrupted for brief periods, we know by other evidence pretty
well where Thompson was. I worked for several weeks at Toronto, in 1894 and
1895, studying these manuscripts and preparing a minute digest of Thompson's
Journals for the period said —1789-1812. The net result of this research, in
so far as it bears in any way upon Henry, will be found embodied in y notes.
It has long been a matter of regret among those versed in
the history and geography of the Greater Northwest that this luminous record
of the life-work of so modest, so meritorious an explorer as Thompson was—of
so scientific a surveyor and so great a discoverer—has never seen the light,
either under government patronage or by private enterprise. I had serious
thoughts at one time of undertaking to edit Thompson, at least for the
period down to 1812; and I reluctantly abandoned the idea only after
examination of the materials had satisfied me that I could advise no
publisher to bring out such a work, as it would be expensive beyond any
reasonable prospect of reimbursement. The difficulty in the case is, that so
much of the manuscript consists of astronomical calculations, traverse
tables, and other mathematical data, without which the matter would cease to
be Thompsonian, yet with which it would be largely unreadable and quite
unsalable. Even the ostensibly narrative portions are notably barren of
incident beyond simple statements of arrivals, departures, and the like;
consisting in the main of dated entries which cover little else than
figuring on the formal courses and distances of the routes pursued, with an
eye fixed on geodesy and geography. It is true that Thompson was a fur
trader, and a partner of the Northwest Company, actively engaged in those
commercial ventures upon which his livelihood depended in those days,
exactly as Henry was ; but, unlike the latter, he had no turn for trade, and
never minded the shop. Business was Henry's religion, and science was
Thompson's; each worshiped his own god and ciphered out his own salvation
with equal method and precision—the one figuring out pelf from pelt, the
other casting up accounts of geodetic points. The irony of the event is the
world's revenge on David Thompson; but the world can never be allowed to
forget the discoverer of the sources of the Columbia, the first white man
who ever voyaged on the upper reaches and main upper tributaries of that
mighty river, the pathfinder of more than one way across the Continental
Divide from Saskatchewan and Athabascan to Columbian waters, the greatest
geographer of his day in British America, and the maker of what was then by
far its greatest map—that "Map of the North-West Territory of the Province
of Canada. From actual Survey during the Years 1792 to 1812," as the legend
goes. This map has never before, to my knowledge, been published as a whole
or in any part; and I have therefore the pleasure of calling attention to
the fact that three sections of it, covering most of the immense territory
over which we now accompany Henry, have been traced in facsimile under my
direction expressly for the present work, and should be found in the
cover-pocket of Vol. HI., together with a fourth sheet, which reproduces the
original legend of the whole. These several pieces are reduced to about
one-half the size of the original ; in one or two cases, where the bold
lettering of a name carried part of it beyond the sections transcribed, it
has been independently reduced by the draughtsman; Mr. Harper's copyright of
this imprint has been added to the legend ; otherwise the facsimile is
perfect, for no marks appear upon these sheets save those placed on the
original map by Thompson's own hand.
With the voluminous official archives above described
must not be confounded a small batch of Thompson's papers recently offered
for sale by private parties in Toronto. This manuscript is authentic and
genuine; being a summary autobiography which Thompson wrote very late in
life, perhaps about 1850, apparently in hopes of being able to publish it.
Thompson died Feb. 16th, 1857, at the very advanced age of nearly 87 years,
having been born Apr. 30th, 1770. The handwriting shows painful evidence of
senility, and I should hesitate to trust to his memory for dates and other
details requiring precision of statement. The article is extremely
interesting, and would prove very valuable should it be checked, as it
easily might be, by comparison with his original Journals. I understand that
this manuscript has passed into the excellent hands of Mr. J. B. Tyrrell, of
the Geological Survey of Canada, well known for his own extensive and
important explorations in the Dominion. Mr. Tyrrell has already given us A
Brief Narrative of the Journeys of David Thompson in North-western America,
which was read before the Canadian Institute Mar. 3d, 1888, and published in
advance of the Proceedings by permission of the Council, as an 8vo pamphlet
of pp. 28, Toronto, 1888. It is much to be hoped that this writing may
appear under Mr. Tyrrell's very competent editorship.
To the statement made in opening this Preface, that
Alexander Henry the Younger is an unknown man, exception may be taken to the
extent of recognizing the fact that extracts from certain early portions of
the Coventry copy of the Journal were read by Mr. C. N. Bell before the
Historical and Scientific Society of Manitoba, and published as Transaction
No. 31, 8vo, pp. 9, Winnipeg, 1888. Beyond these extracts, relating to
Henry's residence on the Red river in and before 1801, I am not av^are that
any portion of his manuscript has ever appeared in print before the present
occasion. A copy of that part which relates to his Mandan tour was for some
time in the hands of Rev. E. D. Neill of St. Paul, Minn., by whom it was
made over to me unconditionally, a short time before his death. This
fragment interested me so much that I immediately prepared it for
publication, and had actually handed it in to Mr. Harper, when I was induced
to undertake the whole work.
It will be to consult the convenience of most readers to
give here a concise account of the three parts into which Henry's Journal is
naturally divisible. Part I. is conterminous with Vol. I. Parts H. and HI.
together form Vol. II. The Index alone makes Vol. III. Part I., which I have
entitled " The Red River," runs from 1799 to 1808. After an opening
fragment, Henry is found en route from Grand Portage, on Lake Superior, and
we follow him closely along Rainy river, through the Lake of the
Woods, down Winnipeg river, and through the lake of that name, to the Red
river, up which he proceeds to the mouth of Park river, where he builds his
trading-post for the season of 1800-01. Next year he establishes the Pembina
post, which he occupies with various intermissions till 1808. During this
period he has charge of the Northwest Company^'s interests throughout the
region now included in Minnesota, Manitoba, and North Dakota; he establishes
various outposts, and travels about a great deal. His doings are pictured to
the life, with a realism that rivals a Zola's, and much that he has to say
of the Ojibways and other Indians is of absorbing, even startling, interest.
During this period we accompany him on many journeys, and
see things as they were all over the country. The most notable of these
travels is the Mandan tour of 1806, full of adventure, and full of curious
information regarding the sedentary tribes of the Missouri.
Part II., "The Saskatchewan," shows our hero—our
commercial traveler and mutual friend—in an entirely different environment.
Having been ordered to take charge of one of the Forts des Prairies which
were then operated on the North Saskatchewan, he leaves Pembina and proceeds
through Lake Winnipeg to navigate the great waterway which reaches thence to
the Rocky mountains. This journey is described minutely and graphically,
enabling us to follow every stroke of the paddle, and inciting the editor to
an extensive commentary upon the histogeography of an immense region. During
1808-11 Henry is in charge of three different Saskatchewan posts—Fort
Vermilion, Terre Blanche, and the Rocky Mountain house; he makes long
overland journeys, including one with dog-sledges in the depth of winter to
the Continental Divide; there is not a single mile of the great river he
does not navigate; and he lives in close relations with all the Indian
tribes of Saskatchewan and Alberta, of whom he treats at great length and in
due form, apart from his personal narrative.
In all these wanderings which occupy Parts I. and II.
Henry is either shadowed or foreshadowed by the unique figure of the
ubiquitous David Thompson. I have taken pains to collate my digests of
Thompson's journals with Henry's text, and nowhere else do the two records
so amplify and verify each other as throughout the upper Saskatchewan and
Rocky Mountain region during the years 1808-11. These were exactly the times
of Thompson's most energetic and furthest-reaching exploits. On the Atlantic
side of the mountains the two men were repeatedly together, though they
never seemed to fancy each other particularly; and on the Pacific side, the
scene of travels and discoveries on Thompson's part which Henry did not
share, and concerning which the least has been accurately known of all
Thompson's movements and establishments, I have enjoyed unequaled facilities
for supplementing Henry's narrative with an account of Thompson's operations
in British Columbia, Montana, Idaho, Oregon, and Washington.
Part III., "The Columbia," opens after a break of about
two years in the Henry manuscripts. Late in 1813, Henry has made a
trans-continental journey and appears at Astoria —or Fort George, as it
becomes shortly after his arrival. His Journal of 1813-14, minutely and
precisely kept up to the day before his death by drowning in the mouth of
the Columbia, is particularly valuable as a historical document. Most of his
time was spent at his post, but he also made extensive voyages on the
Columbia and Willamette. At this time Henry was personally associated with
each one of the three men who have been until now our chief authorities upon
the early history of Astoria and the affairs of the Pacific Fur Company,
with which he became thoroughly conversant.
His work is so important a concordance that if Franchere,
Cox, and Ross be regarded as the three synoptical writers of Astoria, then
Henry furnishes the fourth gospel. The extreme interest of this matter has
induced me to go into great detail in my notes, and I have reason to believe
that much new light has been thrown on Astorian history. Had Irving
commanded the resources which Henry places at our disposal, his famous
romance would have been no less entertaining and might have become more
historical. The amount of information which Henry and Thompson give us in
these volumes, together with that which I have contributed to their joint
work, may be appreciated by glancing through the Index, where the names of
persons, places, and other things mentioned in these writings occupy more
than one hundred double-column pages.
There only remains the pleasurable duty of making the
acknowledgments due to those who have in any way facilitated my researches
or otherwise contributed to the general result of these investigations.
Authors whose published writings have been consulted are in each instance
duly cited in my notes; they are very numerous, as I have availed myself of
practically the whole of the literature which bears immediately upon the
subject in hand. But I am more particularly and personally indebted to many
friends and correspondents, both in Canada and in the United States, who
have shown me those official favors without which it would have been
impossible to take up the work, or have cheered and encouraged my labor with
evidences of their interest in its success. I have specially to thank Mr.
Charles C. James, Deputy Minister of Agriculture of the Province of Ontario,
for many friendly attentions rendered, both in person and by correspondence,
throughout the progress of the work, in the course of which he favored me
repeatedly with valued suggestions and criticisms, and was kind enough to
supervise the transcription of the Thompson map. Great courtesies were also
shown me by Mr. Archibald Blue, Director of the Bureau of Mines; by Mr.
Aubrey White, Assistant Commissioner of Crown Lands; Mr. George B.
Kirkpatrick, Director of Surveys, Crown Lands Department, in whose office
the Thompson MSS. are preserved; and by the Members of the Cabinet of the
Legislature of Ontario, which voted to place these records at my
disposition, namely: Hon. Sir Oliver Mowat, Premier and Attorney General
(now Minister of Justice for Canada); Hon. Arthur S. Hardy, Commissioner of
Crown Lands (now Premier of Ontario); Hon. John Dryden, Minister of
Agriculture; Hon. George W. Ross, Minister of Education; Hon. William Harty,
Commissioner of Public Works; Hon. Richard Harcourt, Provincial Treasurer;
Hon. John M. Gibson, Provincial Secretary (now Commissioner of Crown Lands);
and Mr. S. T. Bastedo, Private Secretary of the Premier. The tracing of the
Thompson map was carefully executed by Mr. Charles J. Murphy of Unwin,
Foster, Murphy, and Esten, Draughtsmen, Toronto. The original MSS. of
Gabriel Franchère were shown me by Mr. James Bain, Jr., of the Public
Library of Toronto.
I have further to recognize with gratitude the courtesies
extended to me in person while I was in Ottawa, or subsequently by
correspondence, by Dr. Alfred R. C. Selwyn, Deputy Head and Director of the
Geological Survey of Canada; by his successor in that important office, my
friend Dr. George M. Dawson ; by Professor John Macoun and Mr. J. B.
Tyrrell, both of the same Survey; by Mr. Otto J. Klotz, of the International
Boundary Commission, Department of the Interior; by Mr. Douglas Brymner,
Canadian Archivist, and his assistant, the late Mr. Joseph Marmette.
Permission to copy the Henry MSS. was kindly granted by the authorities of
the Library of Parliament at Ottawa, Mr. A. D. De Celles, General Librarian,
and Mr. Martin J. Grififin, Parliamentary Librarian ; and the transcript was
made under the personal supervision of Mr. Louis Philippe Sylvain, Assistant
Librarian.
I am also under obligations in various ways to Mr. J. M.
LeMoine of Spencer Grange, Quebec; Captain H. M. Chittenden, Corps of
Engineers, U. S. Army ; Mr. O. B. Wheeler, Assistant Engineer, Missouri
River Commission, St. Louis, Mo.; Professor Charles Sprague Sargent, of the
Arnold Arboretum of Harvard University, Jamaica Plain, Mass.; the late
Professor G. Brown Goode, then Director of the U. S. National Museum ; Dr.
Theodore Gill, of the Smithsonian Institution; Major John W. Powell,
Director of the U. S. Bureau of Ethnology; Mr. F. W. Hodge, of the same
Bureau; Mr. Byron Andrews of New York City ; particularly, to Mrs. Mary B.
Anderson of Washington, D. C, who indexed the work so thoroughly that her
co-operation alone forms Vol. Ill,; and finally, to my esteemed publisher,
Mr. Francis P. Harper of New York, whose liberal and enterprising spirit
left me entirely without restrictions regarding the length to which I might
go in editing the Henry-Thompson Journals.
Elliott Coues.
1726 N Street, Washington, D. C.
October 25th, 1896.
You can download these volumes here...
Volume 1 |
Volume 2 |
Volume 3 |