This was a title by
which the venerable and Reverend William Case, otherwise known as “Elder
Case,” was distinguished for many years before his death. It may seem
too broad a title to some, in view of what was achieved by some who
preceded him in the Province as Methodist Itinerants— such as Losee,
Dunham, Coleman, Wooster, Jewel, Sawyer, Bangs, and others—in so far as
the evangelization of the whites was concerned; also in view of the
labors, at some periods and in several places, of ministers of other
branches of the Church of Christ. Yet, when we remember that Case
entered the Province so early as 1805, and that he continued to labor in
it, with the exception of six years, unremittingly down to the day of
his death; and that he was almost the first Missionary to the extreme
western part of the Province; and when we take into account^ that he
projected, fostered, and clung to the last to the Indian Missions ; and
that the last mentioned Missions have been almost exclusively connected
with the Wesleyan Methodist Church, we must see that the cognomen might
pass without much explanation or modification.
Were we to write his
life, we should probably divide it into— His Pre-Aboriginal Efforts ;
and his Indian Missionary Career. And what a fruitful subject to one
familiar with the political and religious history of Canada, would be
the Life and Times of the Bev. Willtam Case. “ Case and his Coadjutors,”
might be its title. He would be a fine central figure, standing out from
the rest, while grouped around him might stand the whole array of
Canadian Methodist worthies, lay as well as clerical, from one end of
the Province to the other, and from eighteen hundred and• Jive, to
eighteen hundred and fifty-five. Strange that his friends have found no
person competent and willing to undertake it.
In the absence of such
a life, we furnish a slight memorial. Like the novelists, we begin in
the middle—namely, at the time we first saw him, in 1824, when he must
have been about forty-four years of age. I had heard my mother speak of
“Elder Case” approvingly, as “a very mild man.” This was to
contradistinguish him from the great majority of Methodist preachers of
that day, who were in general very boisterous and particularly so “Elder
Ryan,” his coadjutor in the Eldership of the Province ; the subject of
our last picture, who, as we have seen, was a Boanerges. At length we
saw him for ourself. The writer had set out a few months before to seek
and serve God; had joined the Methodist Church, and at the time referred
to, was attending a prayer meeting in the house of a Mr. C-, when a
tall, somewhat slender,
round-faced, pleasant
countenanced stranger, genteel looking, in very clerical garb, entered
the room; and at the request ot the more active of the only two
class-leaders then in the town, conducted the meeting. All the older
members pressed around him to shake hands, and were most pleasantly
received. The youngest member, who stood behind the rest, was led
forward by his leader “to speak to the Elder.” He smilingly re marked to
our considerate friend, “I see you have som& young members.” That boy
afterwards learned that the good Elder had given his leader a special
charge concerning him—predicting by the way, that he would yet preach
the Gospel. He took a great interest in young men; and devised measures
to bring them forward, often unknown to them, so as not to elate them
too much at first. He was the director of the rising ministry of the
Methodist Church in Canada before she had a College in which to train
them ; and he was the friend of that Institution from the moment it was
projected to the day of his death, watching its progress and doings with
the most lively interest. He would sometimes talk about “his boys” in
the pulpit in a way that set the young aspirants to usefulness, and to
weeping around him. Little children, too, he loved, and took a great
interest in their schools. On this account, he was a^welcome visitant in
the various families whose hospitality he ^enjoyed. The little Indian
children, even, would literally pluck his clothes, “to share the good
man’s smile.” Nor did they fail in their object. He would often pursue
these tawny little ones, and catching them would kiss them with all the
fondness imaginable."
My next sight of him,
after the occasion referred to, was two years later, when he and the
Hey. Thomas Madden chanced to be together in the pulpit of the Old
Framed Meeting-House—two of the strong men of that day. Case preached
011 “Justification by Faith,” the most doctrinal sermon I ever heard him
deliver; and Madden followed with an address in further elucidation of
the subject. I thought I had never heard anything so satisfactory.
Madden was the clearer in exposition and more methodical in arrangement;
but Case was more declamatory and persuasive. Up to this period he had
been very popular as a preacher ; he became less so after he got
absorbed in the Indian work, and some brighter luminaries arose to
transcend him. Case in the pulpit appeared to the greatest advantage
before eighteen hundred and twenty-five, lie did not excel in
exposition, nor in doctrinal preaching, but in treating historical
subjects—the destruction of Sodom and the case of Zaecheus, for
instance—in preaching on relative duties and family religion; in
portraying domestic scenes; and in a pathetic sort of declamation, to
which his musical voice, his ready utterance, and tearful eyes, all lent
their assistance. The intonations of his voice were not unlike those of
the Indians, which we always thought gave his address a peculiar
persuasiveness to them.
Our subject was born in
1780—converted in 1803—received his first appointment to Canada in 1805.
He continued in this Province till 1807, when he spent one year in the
United States. He returned in 1808, and continued till 1810. Then, after
five years spent on the other side of the lines, he returned and
continued in Canada till the day of his death. He was seventeen years a
Travelling Chairman, or Presiding Elder of various districts; four years
the President of the Conference and Superintendent of the whole work;
and the rest of his time till within a year or two of his death,
exclusively devoted to the Indian work, as Missionary, Superintendent of
Translations, and Principal of Alderville Industrial Institute.
In his relation as the
“Father of the Indian Missions” it will become us particularly to speak
of him. But before doing so, we must glance at the characteristics of
his career among the whites. His early ministry, by the testimony of all
who knew him at that time, was distinguished by activity, tenderness,
and prudence. It is said that after preaching one of his persuasive
sermons, he would sing one of those delightful solos, which he knew so
well how to manage. Then when the young people were all enchained, he
would walk around the room, take each by the hand, or, throwing his arms
around the neck of the young men, he would beseech them to be reconciled
to God. It was by such means he promoted the great revival in the West
in 1808, when the voice of prayer and praise was heard by day and night
in the houses and barns, in the fields and woods, all over the country.
By his singing he found his way on some occasions into the families of
genteel Romanists, to whose children (in one instance a young lady in
dying circumstances) he, in that gentle way, communicated the knowledge
of Christ. Music was his own solace, as well as the means of charming
others. He told us, that in one of his long, solitary, bush rides, on a
close, sultry day, when the feathered songsters were mute and all nature
seemed to lie in a state of torpor, he was quite disposed to feel
dejected; when he stopt, descended from his horse, selected the branch
of a tree that would “ peel,” and made a whistle, with which he
remounted and began to play : his own spirits were revived, his horse
seemed livelier, all the birds began to sing, and he went on his way
rejoicing. He was an early riser; and in later years, when greater
refinement obtained, we have known him to rise before the genteel family
with whom he was sojourning were astir, and call them to see the glories
of a rising sun, and to inhale the balmy breath of morn, by stealing to
the piano and thumbing slowly off some simple, plaintive air.
He was “instant in
season, and out of season.” Onee when pursuing his way on the beach of
one of our great Canadian Lakes, the only passible road at the early day
when the event transpired, he met at a narrow pass a solitary
man—stopped him, and spoke to him of salvation till he began to weep,
then he proposed prayer—alighted from his horse, and wrestled in earnest
intercession in his behalf till God in mercy set his soul at liberty.
The two embraced each other, and went on their opposite ways rejoicing,
perhaps never to meet till they met in heaven. Of his boldness and
adroitness in causing his horse to swim the Niagara River, to avoid the
embargo, when he wished to reach his circuit in the West, all our
readers have learned from his Jubilee Sermon.
Case, though he had
none of the sternness and authority of Ryan, and perhaps was less
methodical than he, was nevertheless a real general. The submission
which others gained by awakening fear, he gained by exciting Jove. He
was a shrewd, though silent observer of character; and knew how to put
the right man in the right place. Many of these men were superior to
himself in point of talent. When the battle for our public rights had to
be fought, he did not draw the pen himself (although no contemptible
writer) but put forth one of the youngest men in the connexion as its
champion, because he knew he was the best qualified of any in the body
for the task. At his Quarterly Meetings he sometimes employed the
stationed minister to preach in his stead, when he thought he was
qualified to make a better impression on the augmented congregation than
himself. If he had circulars to write, he knew what good copyist to put
his hand on to do it for him. We remember his coming into the school we
were attending in 1828, and engaging our teacher to write out for each
preacher in his district a draft of circular which he left; the decision
of the American General Conference on our application to be separated
from that body.
He was “wise as a
serpent, while harmless as a dove.” He never committed himself by a
premature disclosure of his own views; but he had a quiet, unintentional
sort of way of drawing out the views of others. He showed his
self-control in his suppressed laughter. That rule of a “Helper,”
“Converse sparingly, and conduct yourself prudently with women,” was
oxemplarily observed by him from early youth. This was a great
achievement, in view of his youthful beauty, and constant^ exposure to
company. He was near, or quite fifty, before he married. In fact, his
long journeys and absences from home had nearly ceased before he asked-
any lady to share his joys and sorrows. Perhaps no person preserved a
more prudent single life than he. Some pleasant things are told of his
adroitness in disentangling himself from the attentions of fair
candidates for the handsome young preacher’s affections, but we shall
not particularize them.
There can be no doubt
but that his interest in the Indian WORK became a real passion. The
aboriginal tribes which hung on the outskirts of civilization in this
Province, especially the Chippewa Indians, were a most degraded and
besotted race. Ignorant, indolent, improvident, filthy, drunken, and
licentious to the last degree. No one hoped for their amelioration, or
thought it possible. But Case, in his frequent journeys through the
land, had often anxiously revolved their condition in his mind. When,
therefore, Peter Jones, a half-Indian youth, whose vernacular was
Chippewa, and who knew something of English, was converted at a
Camp-Meeting in eighteen hundred and twenty-three, he broke out with the
exclamation—“ Bless God! the door is now opened to the Indian tribes.”
And events transpiring in swift succession verified the prophetic
character of the remark. There was a coincidenec of three favoring
circumstances which proved the work to be providentially commenced. A
zealous young man, a local preacher, Seth Crawford, by name, had come
from the United States, unauthorized, except by what he thought to be a
divine impulse, and commenced a school among the Indians of Grand River.
Coincidently with that, the Bev. A. Torry had been appointed a
Missionary to the scattered white settlers along that stream. Therefore,
when Jones (who now resided with his father near where Crawford had
commenced operations,) was converted, and his half sister also, who was
a Mohawk, there were experienced and pious men at hand to sympathize
with him and to guide and assist him in his efforts for the salvation of
his fellow-countrymen, which began at once. The first conversions took
place among the Mohawks, among whom was an influential chief, Thomas
Davis ; but soon the work broke out among the Chippewas of the Credit,
to which tribe, or band, Peter Jones, by his mother, properly belonged.
For a time the Indian brethren at the G rand Biver gave them a place
among themselves, that they might be near the means of grace and of
instruction. This was before their houses were erected on their own
reservation at the Credit. And it would have been well if all the
converted Indians could have permanently settled together in one place,
and a communityship if not a nationality given to them by which their
efforts towards civilization and self-improvement might have been more
effectually encouraged and brought to some good, productive issue. Even
as it was, great and glorious things were achieved. The Bellville, or
Kingston Indians caught the flame; and it soon spread to Bice Lake, Mud
Lake, Lake Simcoe, Schoogog, Muncey-Town, and St. Clair. No one can
imagine, who did not witness it, how these wonders among the Indian
tribes thrilled the souls and animated the zeal and faith of the old
Methodists of the Province.
Case specially became
absorbed in it, so that his attention to the regular work ever after was
only secondary. He labored, talked, and prayed for the Indians without
weariness. A pleasant story is told of an interview between him and the
renowned Bishop George, in the United States, whither Case had gone as
was his wont frequently, to beg for his Indian Missions. George said
Case was called on to pray; and soon began to pray for the “poor
Indians;” “but soon broke down with emotion—recovered himself, and began
to pray for the Indians again, till he faltered again—praying for the
Indians was alternated with weeping”—“till,” said the Bishop, “he forgot
the white-man had a soul at all.” Though still on a district till 1828,
his spare time was spent at the missions, or in begging for them. The
latter was certainly no sinecure. There were no funds and no
organizations for raising them in those days. Missionary meetings sucK
as we have now were not thought of for several years. The whole was left
to fitful spontaneous effort. Case, like Dr. Coke, went from house to
house and solicited aid, both here and in the United States, sometimes
striving to enhance the interest by the singing and recitations of a few
children from the mission schools. Many of the preachers imitated his
efforts. We know that Ferguson, of precious memory did for one.
But after all that
could be done, the support extended to the laborers—for they well
deserved the name, working with their hands to teach the Indians
agriculture and the mechanic arts, and to raise food for themselves and
families, aud to provide mission houses and chapels—was very slender.
Happily they knew how to forage for themselves. A pack enclosed in a
blanket, slung on the back by means of what was called a tump-line
across the shoulders, and a gun with a small store of powder and shot,
constituted an Indian preacher’s outfit. I knew Elder Case to pull the
socks off his feet to give to one of these extemporized evangelists,
while my own good mother, (peace to her memory I) knit another pair with
all possible dispatch to replace them. He adapted himself to the cuisine
of the Indians—no trifling achievement by the way—and maintained that no
white woman could cook a fish like a squaw.
Case’s calm, quiet, and
yet cheerful manner was adapted to the Indian mind. A blustering,
driving, direct man, could not succeed with them. But he had a method of
administering the most effectual rebuke in a way that would not offend.
The most defective part of the converted Indian’s character is—their
indolence and want of management The good Elder used to hold at
Alderville what he called an “ Inquiry Meeting.” Some scripture
character or piece of history was first discussed by the missionary.
Then the natives were encouraged to ask questions concerning any point
which they had not understood, or about which they wanted more
information. This method was found entertaining and instructive. One
evening the Patriarch Job was the subject. His case awakened a great
deal of curiosity. He was put before them as an example of industry and
economy. His great wealth astonished them much. They wished to know
again how many sheep he had: and were told “seven thousand.” ’’How many
camels?” “Three thousand.” “How many yoke of oxen?” “Five hundred.” “How
many she-asses?” And were told, “Five hundred.” “Now,” said Case in
conclusion, “Suppose Job should pay you a visit, and walk around among
you; and look at the way you farm, and look at your cows, and oxen, and
pigs: What do you think he would say?” “Don’t know. What you think he
say?” "Well, I think he would shake his head, and say, ‘ This catching
musk-rat is a small business’!” The men all dropt their heads. They felt
its force. They departed without saying a word, but they were not
offended; for it passed into a proverb among them, which they applied to
those who neglected agriculture for hunting—“Catching musk-rat is a
small business.” Case’s deep interest in the Missions appeared in his
amassing a library of books almost wholly restricted to that subject.
Thus have we presumed
to record a few of the. incidents of his early career which came to our
own knowledge. The rest will be best expressed in the words of the
official obituary published in the Minutes of Conference for 1856 :—
“Question IV. What
preachers have died since last Conference?* “Answer. “WILLIAM CASE.
“From the
autobiographical part of the venerable deceased Minister’s valuable “
Jubilee Sermon” we learn that he was born at Swansea, a town of
Massachusetts, on the 27th of August, 1780; and he died, soon after a
fall from his horse, at the Wesleyan Indian Mission of Alnwick, in
Western Canada, October 19th, 1855,—his departure, which was expected by
few persons, universally regretted by his brethren, friends, and the
public, though a gracious Providence had permitted him to reach the
honored age of seventy-five.
“The eventful period
when he assumed the Christian profession is thus briefly stated by him:
“After years of religious impressions, and a sinful course, I was
converted in 1803.” Under what circumstances this change took place he
has not informed us; but of the fact, so necessary to ministerial
fitness, satisfaction, and efficiency, there is no doubt; for in every
subsequent year, and in all the vicissitudes of an itinerant life, his
character was adorned with those features which bespeak a renewed mind,
and entire consecration to God. He had not received the spirit of
bondage again to fear, but the spirit of adoption, whereby he cried
Abba, Father; and we believe that spirit was a permanent resident in his
soul. At no time was there evidence that the peace he professed was
fluctuating, and that the light of his heavenly Father’s countenance had
become dim. In his exhibition of the graces of the Holy Spirit there was
neither uncertainty nor extravagance; and even to old age |