Services as Executive
Councillor.—Sir Peregrine Maitland and his Administration.—The Church in
York.—Appointment to the Legislative Council.
THE subject of
Emigration engaged, at this period, a good deal of the public attention
in Upper Canada; and the question which just now most perplexed the
Government was the granting of lands to in-coming settlers. Amongst the
latter was a considerable number of half-pay officers, both of the Army
and Navy; many of whom,—especially of the latter,—became excellent
settlers, and turned their lands to profitable account. The wiser
portion of these purchased cleared farms in the front townships, which
they were able to obtain at a moderate cost; and there they lived
comfortably amidst a respectable population, and without any serious
loss of their old social advantages. The transition from the comforts
and refinements of their mother-land was thus less sensibly felt: they
became better contented with their new lot; and generally a church and
school were accessible. They drew, of course, the lands to which they
were entitled, and performed what was called the “settlement duties.”
This meant, the clearing, in a very slovenly way, of a certain
proportion of the lands granted, and the opening of their share of the
roads contiguous to their farms. Great complaints were made that this
was money thrown away; for this partial clearing,—little more than the
slashing down of trees,—-was attended with no present benefit either to
the public or to the proprietor. Still, it was necessary to enforce
actual settlement, as far as possible; and it was difficult for the
Executive to devise means by which this could he effected with advantage
to the country, and justice at the same time to those who received these
grants of lands.
It seems, too, that the
question of admitting settlers from the United States was just now very
earnestly discussed; and here the clear judgment and practical knowledge
of Dr. Strachan proved to be of great value. What his views upon this
subject were, are best expressed in his own language, in a letter to
Colonel, afterwards Sir John Harvey, bearing date June 22nd, 1818:—
“Allow me to give you a
brief notice of the true state of the controversy concerning the
admission of settlers from the United States; which 1 do in confidence,
depending upon your discretion to bear it in mind, should you think it
necessary hereafter to write upon the subject.
“General Simcoe, being
very extensively acquainted in the States, and knowing that great
numbers of the inhabitants were still loyalists, and desirous of coming
into the countiy, encouraged them to remove into the Province, and
procured for all that appeared in Upper Canada before June, 1798, and
who could prove their adherence to Great Britain, valuable privileges.
Many of these persons had formed connexions iu the United States, and
were anxious to bring them in likewise. General Simcoe, though very
hostile to the Americans in general, admitted this,—at first sparingly,
afterwards more generally. This relaxation was gradually extended; and
during the time of his successor, President Russell, people were
received promiscuously from the States, without let or hindrance. This
became a subject of great complaint throughout the Province.
“General Hunter
endeavoured to check this indiscriminate introduction of Americans, and
to bring matters back to the rule on which General Simcoe acted. The
same policy was continued, by Governor Gore previous to the late war,
notwithstanding the reception of several memorials from different
Districts, exhibiting its impolicy.
“During the war, the
danger of the promiscuous introduction of settlers from the States, was
most severely felt: In several Districts, where they were the majority,
or supposed themselves to be so, rebellion was organized. This was
particularly the case in the London District, and would have been still
more so in the Home District, but for the prompt energy of a few. Tn the
Newcastle District, the disposition to rebel was great; but finding
themselves too near Kingston and York, they were afraid to attempt an
open outbreak, but deserted in great numbers. In the County of Leeds,
nearly three hundred militiamen deserted to the enemy.
“These defections, and
the danger to which they exposed the loyal inhabitants, were fresh in
our minds when peace was restored; and so it was deemed wise to check
emigration from the United States for a time, until the passions on both
sides were a little cooled, and until a sort of foundation, or nucleus,
could be formed of emigrants from the mother country in the new
settlements; by which they might acquire a British tone and character.
After this, to slide gradually, and quietly, into the system pursued
before the late war.
“This judicious plan
did not correspond with the sel6sh views of some great land speculators,
who wished the immediate and promiscuous admission of Americans, that
they might have a market for their land These foolish persons conjured
up the 13th of George II. to their aid,—a law which respects foreign
protestants only, and has no reference to Americans; and if it had, no
American would comply with the conditions it requires. The modification
of this law by the 30th George III. may be construed to extend its
provisions to the Americans; but not one of them has ever complied with
these provisions. The truth is, they have been permitted to hold lands
by an indulgence which cannot be defended by law; and as they have never
conformed themselves to the conditions required, nothing could be more
foolish, impolitic, and dangerous than calling the matter up. It would
bring up several delicate questions about the Oath of Allegiance, and
who are, or are not, subjects; questions which had better sleep. At the
same time, no person from the States would consider his title secure, or
be able to bring a writ of ejectment against another who had got
possession of his property. In short, the avoiding of a great number of
legal difficulties appears to have been the object of Government, and I
am well assured they had no other feeling, nor could have had any other
oh the subject.”
Consequent upon the
war, several changes had taken place in the administration of the
Provincial Government. When the war broke out in 1812, Mr. Francis Gore,
who had been for some years the Lieutenant Governor, felt it his duty to
surrender the administration of the Government into the hands of one who
could combine with it the command of the military forces; and
consequently both the civil and military government of the Province were
assigned to Major General Sir Isaac Brock. Soon after the close of the
war, Mr. Gore returned to Upper Canada, and resumed the administration
of the Government. This gentleman was held in high estimation at the
capital, for his social as well as official qualities; and with Dr.
Strachan he was always on the most friendly and intimate terms. Upon his
departure from the Province, about two years after, the administration
of public affairs devolved upon the senior member of the Executive
Council, the Hon. Samuel Smith; and perhaps no one was more ready than
Mr. Smith himself to acknowledge that the delegation of such a
responsibility by the rule of seniority, is not the happiest arrangement
that could have been devised. It was regarded as a cause of general
congratulation, when it was announced that the appointment of Lieutenant
Governor of Upper Canada was conferred upon Major General Sir Peregrine
Maitland. In a letter to Mr. Gore, dated December 8th, 1818, Dr.
Strachan writes of him as follows:—
“Sir Peregime is a most
amiable and pious man, and comes out most anxious to do all the good he
can. He arrived here with some ideas respecting the Executive Government
not founded on sufficient evidence; but he now sees things more clearly.
He is a man of great talent, and much simplicity of manner and habit; at
the same time he is firm and resolute. Those who presumed upon his
favour because they had taken umbrage at you, found themselves totally
mistaken. On that ground he was very high indeed. He is thoroughly the
gentleman, and speaks of you, when occasion introduces your name, with
great respect. We are at no pains to conceal our attachments, and he has
too much good sense to be offended: on the contrary, he prizes us the
more. This gentlemanly trait of character endears him to us all.
“Accustomed to the
promptness of military command, he has been sometimes a little too hasty
in taking steps which had been usually the result of consultation; but
this has been entirely from inadvertence, and not from any desire to
assume extraordinary power. He is yet new in civil matters, but his
diligence is incessant, and in a short time he will be completely master
of them.
“His great anxiety to
look into every thing, injures his health, which is extremely delicate.
He keeps much to himself; has no particular adviser; and inquires, and
thinks, and decides for himself.
“He has been so very
short a period here, that it is as yet impossible to draw exact
conclusions; but as far as I can judge from many conversations with him,
he will grow upon acquaintance, and beget stronger and stronger
attachment In all this I may be mistaken, more especially as 1 cannot
pretend to any particular intimacy; but hope that 1 judge correctly.
“The truth is, that his
remark upon are presentation, in which your name was coupled with
something improper, won my heart. On hearing this, I had said, ‘The
thing is utterly false. Governor Gore had been too good to the writer
and to the friend whom he recommended.' He turned mildly, and said,
‘that remark is the very thing which would have induced me to refuse the
prayer.’ ”
The following letter,
addressed to Colonel Nichol, will be read with interest. Many in the
Province will recollect the Colonel as an active and talented man, but
who uniformly took up the opposition side in politics, and was rather
fond of antagonism to the ruling powers. He was a well-read man, and a
pleasant companion; and although he was a warm politician and very
outspoken in his opinions, he seemed to have had no personal enemies.
His tragical death, from being precipitated on a dark night, with horse
and light waggon, over the heights above Queenston, awoke universal
sympathy and regret. The letter that follows, is dated February 23rd,
1819 :—
“I have an opportunity
of franking your brother’s manuscript. The subject is handled with
ability, and does him great credit. I hope that he will iind it his
interest to remain in this country; it is a great benefit to have a man
of talent among us. Owing, I believe, to the writing, it was not read by
the Governor; but it was most favourably reported to him, as indeed it
richly deserved.
“It has been whispered,
since your departure, that you are to commence your parliamentary
career, 1. with moving a vote of censure on Governor Gore; 2. that the
right of granting lands belongs to the Assembly, or Parliament, and not
to the King or his Representative in Council.
“I suspect that these
are fabrications of your enemies, and I have said so but as they were
repeated, I beg to know whether 1 am right. At present you stand well in
this quarter, and your abilities enable you to do much good to the
Province, as well as to yourself. I should, therefore, be sorry to see
them wasted upon matters that are sure to raise contention, and that
cannot fail of being most injurious, without producing any good.
“As to the first, it
would come very ill from you on many accounts. If it be for proroguing
the House, even supposing him wrong (which I for one am not prepared to
do), it was only an error of judgment : his right to do it, when he
thought proper, is undeniable.
“I could say much on
the inexpediency, as well as injustice of such a resolution,
independently of the unpleasant feelings it must excite; but I am afraid
of missing the post, aud therefore pass to the second.—the absurdity of
which excites my astonishment.
“Thirty years ago this
Province was a wilderness. The King gives small portions of it to the
refugees, to disbanded soldiers, to a few immigrants, and some aliens;
and now these persons, still living on his Majesty’s bounty, turn round
and tell him that he had no power to give them what they now possess,
for the land is entirely their own,
“My conclusion is, that
the whole is a fabrication to lessen your weight with your friends, and
to induce a belief that your influence in Parliament will be exerted in
raising disturbances, and not in bringing forward and digesting
excellent measures, so necessary for our peace and prosperity.
“Being one gf those who
have always been anxious for your success in life, and ready at all
times to do justice to your talents, I should regret extremely to be
obliged to differ from you on political grounds; more especially as we
commonly agreed till the resolutions were brought forward. 1 shall only
add, that, in ‘every thing else, I have been more zealously your
supporter than most of those whom you supposed warmer friends.
"When I differ in
opinion from any of my friends, I tell them so candidly, that we may
perfectly understand each other; and this must be my apology for this
letter, unless you are pleased to add my anxiety to appear more
effectually in your defence.”
Mention has already
been made of the “Loyal and Patriotic Society,” designed for the relief
of sufferers by the war. The funds contributed for this object were very
considerable; large subscriptions were obtained in the Province; and
some aid was sent by generous individuals in the mother country. A vast
amount of good was effected by means of this Society; and now, in 1819,
it was found that there was a surplus at its disposal of £4,000. Colonel
Nichol, disappointed in certain views of his own regarding the
appropriation of this fimd, contended for its distribution amongst such
individuals as should shew that they had been sufferers by the war. Dr.
Strachan very wisely opposed this proposition; and as his remarks have a
useful, practical bearing, and may be serviceable at all times, we quote
the following from a letter to a friend in England:—
“To guard against
misconception and evince our adherence to the principle upon which the
Society was originally constituted, we have made some little alteration
in the resolutions first adopted, in regard to the application of our
surplus. They now stand as follows:
“Resolved 1. That of
the remaining funds of the Loyal and Patriotic Society, £2000 be
appropriated to the erection of an Hospital at York, in the Home
District; and two several sums of £100 each, to such other two or more
Districts of this Province as shall, within a year, raise the largest
sum in aid of such appropriation for the erection of two other
Hospitals.
“Resolved 2. That the
Directors of the Hospitals thus erected, shall at all times be prepared
to answer the orders of the Treasurer of the Loyal and Patriotic Society
to the amount of the interest, annually, of the sums thus given them.
“You will perceive that
these resolutions, in fact, fund the money and insure the interest of
it,—to be expended in relieving actual distress of sufferers by the late
war, or finding them an asylum within the Hospitals. And, in order to
make the benefit general as well as permanent, other two Hospitals are
contemplated; one, we presume, at Niagara, and the other at Kingston. We
did not designate the places in our resolutions to avoid giving offence
to the other Districts.
At those two places, as
well as here, the Lieutenant Governor intends giving great assistance;
but, without this money, the buildings could not be erected for many
years. I am persuaded that the subscribers, if the matter were explained
to them, would highly approve the plan adopted by the. Directors, as it
gives a permanency to their benevolence, infinitely more useful than to
expend it upon promiscuous claimants, by whom we should in many cases be
deceived. During the War it was easy to ascertain proper objects; but
after five years of peace, this is impossible, except in the case of
those who have been severely wounded. For such the Hospitals afford an
asylum; or if they have families, a small pension could be given them
out of the interest.
Few in Toronto are
probably aware of the manner in which the General Hospital in this City
was started; an institution which, notwithstanding some mishaps, is
destined, we trust, to extend to future generations, the blessings it
has conferred upon the past.
Political and other
secular matters necessarily engaged some portion of the time and
energies of Dr. Strachan, but the interests of the Church occupied the
largest share of both; and to the forwarding of these, whether local or
general, his characteristic vigour and activity were faithfully applied.
In a letter to. the Secretary of the Society for the Propagation of the
Gospel in Foreign Parts, dated January 5th, 1820, we have an evidence of
this; and the contents will be interesting, as eliciting pleasant
comparisons between the one humble wooden Church of those days, and the
numerous, substantial and capacious ones that exist now:—
“I mentioned, in my
last, that our Church had become much too small for our increasing
congregation, and that it was being enlarged. The repairs and additions
cost £1700, a sum which, large as it is, was subscribed for with great
alacrity by the parishioners, on condition of their being repaid from
the sale of the pews. This sale took place last January; and such was
the competition that they sold for more than covers the debt. The Church
is sixty-six feet by sixty, with a neat altar and a steeple.
“The Hon. George
Crookshank, the Receiver-General, presented rich silk damask coverings
for the pulpit, reading, and clerk’s desks, and the altar table.
“The communicants have
increased from thirty-five to sixty-four. There is a flourishing Sunday
School consisting of upwards of thirty girls and fifty boys. The girls
are taught by three young ladies,—grand-daughters of the Hon. The Chief
Justice. There is likewise a Sunday School attached to the Chapel in the
country, where I preach once a month. Once every quarter these Schools
are brought together and examined, presents of books given them by His
Excellency the Lieutenant-Governor and Lady Sarah Maitland, who interest
themselves exceedingly in promoting the advancement of true religion.”
Towards the end of the
year 1820, his appointment as Legislative Councillor took place. The
manner in which it was made, is probably not much known; so we subjoin
his account of it in a letter to the Bishop of Quebec:—
“The great addition
made to the Representation of this Province in the House of Assembly, by
the law passed last winter, has induced His Excellency Sir Peregrine
Maitland to recommend some new members for seats in the Legislative
Council. His Excellency placed me among the number, without any previous
consultation; as it was necessary for him to have a confidential person
in the Council through whom to make communications,—a service which the
Chief Justice is frequently prevented rendering on account of his
position as Speaker."
The acceptance of this
honour was attended with some pecuniary sacrifice, as it rendered
necessary his resignation of the office of Chaplain to the Legislative
Council. To this situation a salary of £50 per annum was originally
attached; but for the past four years it had been raised to £100 per
annum. The Chaplaincy thus relinquished, was conferred upon the Rev.
William Macaulay, then Incumbent of Cobourg, and was held by him for
several years. |